Robert Reich blogs about the inverse relationship between politicians' sound and fury and helpful results.
Continued here.
Friday, October 9, 2009
In Bangkok US talks "green eggs and ham"
Guardian reports:
According to the Guardian report, the US negotiator is boasting about an "80 billion green economic stimulus package." That kind of talk sounds really disingenuous -- it's spin to my ears. I thought the point of the talks was to discuss actual targets and actual achievements, not boast about domestic spending programs which may or may not produce the intended results. Personally, I think taxes are the only way to ensure the market is behind green policies, not green pork (Green eggs and ham?).
Meanwhile, on Capital Hill the Democrats have already given away 85% of pollution permits in the propsed US cap and trade bill to the country's biggest polluters.
Continued here.
The US threatened to derail a deal on global climate change today in a public showdown with China by expressing deep opposition to the existing Kyoto protocol. The US team also urged other rich countries to join it in setting up a new legal agreement which would, unlike Kyoto, force all countries to reduce emissions.Oxfam's representative at the talks claims this tactic marks 'a detour" from the "road map" agreed to at the Bali Climate Change Talks.
In a further development, the EU sided strongly with the US in seeking a new agreement, but said that it hoped the best elements of Kyoto could be kept. China and many developing countries immediately hit back stating that the protocol, the world's only legally binding commitment to get countries to reduce emissions, was "not negotiable".
According to the Guardian report, the US negotiator is boasting about an "80 billion green economic stimulus package." That kind of talk sounds really disingenuous -- it's spin to my ears. I thought the point of the talks was to discuss actual targets and actual achievements, not boast about domestic spending programs which may or may not produce the intended results. Personally, I think taxes are the only way to ensure the market is behind green policies, not green pork (Green eggs and ham?).
Meanwhile, on Capital Hill the Democrats have already given away 85% of pollution permits in the propsed US cap and trade bill to the country's biggest polluters.
Continued here.
Thursday, October 8, 2009
Muslim population of the world
One in four of us is a Muslim according to a recent Pew Study.
The study notes that "previously published estimates of the size of the global Muslim population have ranged widely, from 1 billion to 1.8 billion." The Pew study pegs the number at 1.57 billion (23 percent of the total global population of 6.8 billion). There are 2.25 billion Christians. Some facts about the world's Muslim population might surprise you:
The study notes that "previously published estimates of the size of the global Muslim population have ranged widely, from 1 billion to 1.8 billion." The Pew study pegs the number at 1.57 billion (23 percent of the total global population of 6.8 billion). There are 2.25 billion Christians. Some facts about the world's Muslim population might surprise you:
- India has more Muslims than any country except for Indonesia and Pakistan..
- China has more Muslims than Malaysia (or Syria).
- Germany has more Muslims than Lebanon.
- And Russia has more Muslims than Jordan and Libya put together.
- 15% of all Muslims live in sub-Saharan Africa and another 15% live in Southeast Asia.
Of the total Muslim population, 10-13% are Shia Muslims and 87-90% are Sunni Muslims. Most Shias (between 68% and 80%) live in just four countries: Iran, Pakistan, India and Iraq.Graphic: Pew designed an impressive interactive map -- see here. A "weighted" map is here.
In four countries - Iran, Azerbaijan, Bahrain and Iraq - Shia Muslims make up a majority of the total population.
Montesquieu on global citizenship
"If I knew something that would serve my country but would harm mankind, I would never reveal it; for I am a citizen of humanity first and by necessity, and a citizen of France second, and only by accident."
~ Montesquieu
~ Montesquieu
Did the Economist inadvertantly kill globalization?
It would be quite the irony if the choice of cover illustration for the world's most stalwart free-trade publication created a kind of "ripple-effect" that brought this "golden age of globalization" to an early end (Perhaps not so golden to you, but golden from the perspective of the Economist).James Fallows blogged that "the mainstream economics press had gone (predictably) berserk in overreacting to the shock-horror nightmare of the Obama administration's tariff on imported Chinese tires." Fallows explained:
There is not now, and there never was, a serious possibility that this would escalate into some sweeping, self-intensifying, global-recovery-threatening "trade war." The many publications and commentators who raised their hands in "Oh no! It's Smoot Hawley again!" horror need to calm down -- and to have their tendency toward over-reaction noted for the record. Yes, I'm talking about you, Economist magazine cover-designers (last week's cover image, below), but you had tons of company.That was my reaction. The story seemed way overblown. But the question begs to be asked: might such overreaction on the part of the mainstream media water the seeds of discord in otherwise barren soil? I no longer think this question is mere speculation.
On Sunday the Indian state of Kerala erupted in massive protests over the ASEAN-India Free Trade Agreement. The FTA is viewed by many Kerala farmers -- including rubber plantation workers -- as a threat to their livelihoods. This commentary by V.R. Krishna Iyer, formerly a judge of the Supreme Court of India, published in the business section of The Hindu, caught my attention:... Kerala’s rubber sector, in particular, will vanish if the free import of rubber from outside India under the FTA is allowed. Pepper, coconut, plantation products and similar commodities which form the backbone of Kerala’s economy will die, too.____
When Chinese tyres offered at fabulously cheap rates threatened the American tyre industry, President Barack Obama imposed 30 to 40 per cent duty on the import of tyres in order to save the American tyre industry. The same Obama strategy of imposing heavy import duties to protect the farmers of the State ought to be instantly imposed here. And to that extent, the ASEAN agreement should be made subject to nationalist conditions.
I protested as part of what was called a human chain against the FTA that was organised across Kerala on October 2, out of concern for swaraj, agriculture, and the peasants and workers of Kerala. Why not copy Mr. Obama in this matter: India is readily adopting America in many other matters, after all.
Photo WorkersForum h/t Ida
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
How should the US engage Burma?
How should the US engage Burma? How best can the US help the people of Burma?
This post is based on my jots from the recent Senate hearing on US-Burma relations. (For an overview of the hearing see, "Burma is not Vietnam." See also "Burmese slam Senate hearings" and "US Senate AWOL on Burma.")
The first step towards engaging Burma is to convince the country's paranoid junta that you have no plans to invade or bomb their country. Given that the US has done plenty of invading and bombing over the years, that's a tough sell. Especially to a group of generals who live in a fortified bunker-city deep in the jungle. Anyway, this problem was the focus of an exchange between the senator chairing the meeting and the Dep. Sec. of State.
Sen. Webb asked Dep. Sec. of State Kurt Campbell about "covert funding to exile groups."
Campbell replied, "Another forum would be a better place to address that issue."
"We shall pursue that in another forum" replied Sen. Jim Webb.
Sen. Webb asked Campbell if he would like to comment on any exile groups that might want to overthrow the government; Webb asked whether Campbell had had made it "clear" during his recent meetings with Mynamar "that we have no military objectives to overthrow their government?"
Campbell replied that "we need to make it clear" to the Burmese through "dialogue" that we "have no intention to overthrow the government."
.
Thant Myint-U, an author and scholar, stressed that key opportunities had been missed. New leadership had brought in satelite TV, and so on, the government had sought engagement but the US had not reciprocated. Had we not stood in the way of gradual change, there would have been more change for the better.
Myint-U said that "a new generation of leaders, aged 40-50, is coming up in Burma. They lack combat experience." Myint-U explained that the transition to the new constitution will coincide with a change in Burma to a new, younger group of leaders.
"Unexpected changes" are likely, he said, especially as constitutionally mandated change coincides with changes within the ranks of the army.
Thant Myint-U emphasized the importance of "elite exposure." He said we need to influence the minds of the officer corps. Myint-U made several other suggestions:
Steinberg suggested that the US and Burma relations were at a "critical nexus." And, asking what might be done, listed five things, but emphasized that the US needs to "set its sights as changes occur in society, and the country becomes more open."
David Williams of Indiana University spoke of the Karin as the Scotch Irish of the hills, a fiercely independent people. "They need our help," he said.
Williams spoke of "suffering on a Biblical scale" along Burma's borders. He described an epidemic of rapes. "Reading individual accounts of women is excruciating" he said, describing one woman who was raped while reaping rice.
Williams said the US should supply cross-border aid (not just to refugees on the Thailand side), demand an end to these attacks on civilians, and initiate trilateral talks which include both the NLD and the military junta.
__
Photos: by Jotman. Top left, Sen. Jim Webb. On the right is Kurt Campbell.
This post is based on my jots from the recent Senate hearing on US-Burma relations. (For an overview of the hearing see, "Burma is not Vietnam." See also "Burmese slam Senate hearings" and "US Senate AWOL on Burma.")
The first step towards engaging Burma is to convince the country's paranoid junta that you have no plans to invade or bomb their country. Given that the US has done plenty of invading and bombing over the years, that's a tough sell. Especially to a group of generals who live in a fortified bunker-city deep in the jungle. Anyway, this problem was the focus of an exchange between the senator chairing the meeting and the Dep. Sec. of State.
Sen. Webb asked Dep. Sec. of State Kurt Campbell about "covert funding to exile groups."
Campbell replied, "Another forum would be a better place to address that issue."
"We shall pursue that in another forum" replied Sen. Jim Webb.
Campbell replied that "we need to make it clear" to the Burmese through "dialogue" that we "have no intention to overthrow the government."
.
Thant Myint-U, an author and scholar, stressed that key opportunities had been missed. New leadership had brought in satelite TV, and so on, the government had sought engagement but the US had not reciprocated. Had we not stood in the way of gradual change, there would have been more change for the better.
Myint-U said that "a new generation of leaders, aged 40-50, is coming up in Burma. They lack combat experience." Myint-U explained that the transition to the new constitution will coincide with a change in Burma to a new, younger group of leaders.
"Unexpected changes" are likely, he said, especially as constitutionally mandated change coincides with changes within the ranks of the army.
Thant Myint-U emphasized the importance of "elite exposure." He said we need to influence the minds of the officer corps. Myint-U made several other suggestions:
- use disaster risk reduction towards this ends
- lift the ban on the import of garments.
- encourage the shift from military to civilian rule by increasing the competency of civilian technocrats.
Steinberg suggested that the US and Burma relations were at a "critical nexus." And, asking what might be done, listed five things, but emphasized that the US needs to "set its sights as changes occur in society, and the country becomes more open."
- A US ambassador to Burma needs approval, confirmation by the Senate.
- Humanitarian assistance needs upgrading.
- Minority questions are paramount, and must be addressed.
- Rohingya problem is tops. "These stateless people on the Burma-Bangladesh border are the most deprived of all Burma's minorities."
- Restrictions on NGOs dating back to 2006 need to be lifted.
David Williams of Indiana University spoke of the Karin as the Scotch Irish of the hills, a fiercely independent people. "They need our help," he said.
Williams spoke of "suffering on a Biblical scale" along Burma's borders. He described an epidemic of rapes. "Reading individual accounts of women is excruciating" he said, describing one woman who was raped while reaping rice.
Williams said the US should supply cross-border aid (not just to refugees on the Thailand side), demand an end to these attacks on civilians, and initiate trilateral talks which include both the NLD and the military junta.
__
Photos: by Jotman. Top left, Sen. Jim Webb. On the right is Kurt Campbell.
Police brutality at the Pittsburgh G20
Sullivan wants to know why Pittsburgh "looked more like Tehran in June than America in September." Radley Balko of Reason posted a fairly comprehensive overview of the way police handled civilians during the G20 in Pittsburgh. Balko notes, "the disquieting ease with which authorities are willing to crush dissent—and at the very sorts of events where the right to dissent is the entire purpose of protecting free speech. That is, events where influential policymakers meet to make high-level decisions with far-reaching consequences." Of particular concern to Balko is the observation that police were apparently dressed in military fatigues (I'm not sure how we can be certain they were't military, since thousands of Iraq-hardened reservists had been deployed for the summit). Video:
Balko's piece overlooks some points that had struck me as significant I was concerned about the precedent set in Pittsburgh of the police using sonic weapons against the public. I was also startled -- saddened really -- by Obama's reaction to the G20 protests.
Commendably, grad student Emily Tanner live-blogged the Pittsburgh protests and their aftermath.
Balko's piece overlooks some points that had struck me as significant I was concerned about the precedent set in Pittsburgh of the police using sonic weapons against the public. I was also startled -- saddened really -- by Obama's reaction to the G20 protests.
Commendably, grad student Emily Tanner live-blogged the Pittsburgh protests and their aftermath.
Tuesday, October 6, 2009
Credit Default Swaps still going strong
One year ago today I blogged a post about Credit Default Swaps. These have widely been blamed for the financial crisis. "The instruments themselves are at the heart of this mess," said one expert at the time.
A recent Bloomberg article begins, "A year after the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., credit-default swaps have lost their stigma for disaster and are contributing to the growing confidence in the credit markets."
Some opinions from the article:
So what's being done?
The story ends on this depressing note:
A recent Bloomberg article begins, "A year after the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., credit-default swaps have lost their stigma for disaster and are contributing to the growing confidence in the credit markets."
Some opinions from the article:
“A functioning credit-default swaps market contributes to more efficient extension of credit” by giving investors and lenders confidence that the industry won’t implode, said Alexander Yavorsky, a senior analyst at Moody’s Investors Service in New York. The consequences of Lehman’s failure “were astronomical, broadly speaking, but the CDS market worked well,” he said.....(A heroine addict needs to shoot up every day too. This gives the adict "confidence" to continue his self-destructive lifestyle.)
“The only market that I know of that seems to have worked virtually every day has been the CDS market,” Eraj Shirvani, chairman of ISDA and Credit Suisse Group AG’s head of fixed income for Europe, the Middle East and Africa, told reporters yesterday at the industry group’s regional meeting in New York....(No matter how bad things get, the market for drugs never shuts down.)
I don't know about you, but I'm inclined to listen to Soros, one of the few guys who anticipated the whole meltdown. On the other hand, why would anyone pay any attention to what anyone associated with either Moody's or Credit Suisse has to say? Why does Bloomberg even bother to quote these people? Rating agencies like Moody's are under investigation today because they failed to inform investors of the true risks. Credit Suisse Group lost billions.
George Soros says the market is still unsafe. The 79-year- old billionaire investor said in an interview that credit- default swaps are “toxic” and “a very dangerous derivative” because it’s easier and potentially more profitable for investors to bet against companies using them than through so- called short sales.
So what's being done?
New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo began investigating whether credit-default swaps were manipulated to spread rumors about financial companies and drive down stock prices, a person in his office who asked not to be identified by name said at the time.(Doesn't sound like that investigation was too serious.)
President Barack Obama said in a June 17 speech on his plans for finance industry regulatory reform that credit swaps and other derivatives “have threatened the entire financial system.”(He gave another speech).
U.S. Congresswoman Maxine Waters, a California Democrat, introduced a bill in July that tried to ban credit-default swaps because she said they permitted speculation responsible for bringing the financial system to its knees.(Lots of bills get introduced.)
The Obama administration sent Congress proposed legislation last month that would require the most active contracts in the $592 trillion over-the-counter derivatives market to be backed by clearinghouses and traded either on an exchange or on regulated systems.(They waited until August -- one whole year -- to introduce legislation that would regulate, not prevent the trading of CDS, and not all kinds of CDS at that!)
The story ends on this depressing note:
“'The industry is starting to feel the future is not looking as bleak as it was in terms of what regulations would be imposed,' said Jeremy Jennings-Mares, a partner in the capital markets group at Morrison & Foerster LLP in London...."
Bangkok climate talks: China notes lack of progress
At the Bangkok Climate Change Talks, the developing world, led by China, wants Kyoto provisions strengthened. The Kyoto treaty, of course, had put the onus for cuts on first world countries.
Continued here.
Continued here.
Monday, October 5, 2009
Dalai Lama, Obama will not meet
American liberals and conservatives often find common cause when it comes to humanitarian foreign policy questions. Is Obama determined to unite the country in opposition to his administration over these kinds of issues?
Last week I blogged Burmese dissidents' fears that the Obama Administration was preparing to cozy up with Burma's dictators. This week begins with a White House announcement that is sure to anger Tibetan exiles, friends of Tibet, and other critics of the Chinese government's record on human rights. WaPo reports:
This was another political miscalculation on the part of Obama. The president is bound to pay a political price for it. A narrative is beginning to develop that Obama is unprincipled, and only interested in appeasing powerful people, be they bankers, insurance company executives, or the Chinese.
Last week I blogged Burmese dissidents' fears that the Obama Administration was preparing to cozy up with Burma's dictators. This week begins with a White House announcement that is sure to anger Tibetan exiles, friends of Tibet, and other critics of the Chinese government's record on human rights. WaPo reports:
In an attempt to gain favor with China, the United States pressured Tibetan representatives to postpone a meeting between the Dalai Lama and President Obama until after Obama's summit with his Chinese counterpart, Hu Jintao, scheduled for next month, according to diplomats, government officials and other sources familiar with the talks.Same old story: sensible intentions, inept execution. I agreed with the spirit behind the recent White House moves on Burma, but I thought the execution was extremely sloppy. The Deputy Secretary of State came out in agreement with this assessment. Similarly, I think it's good that Obama wants to improve relations with China, but I believe this must not be done in such a way as to give the appearance that the US has compromised its principles, or kow-towed.
For the first time since 1991, the Tibetan spiritual leader will visit Washington this week and not meet with the president. Since 1991, he has been here 10 times. Most times the meetings have been "drop-in" visits at the White House. The last time he was here, in 2007, however, George W. Bush became the first sitting president to meet with him publicly, at a ceremony at the Capitol in which he awarded the Dalai Lama the Congressional Gold Medal, Congress's highest civilian award.
The U.S. decision to postpone the meeting appears to be part of a strategy to improve ties with China that also includes soft-pedaling criticism of China's human rights and financial policies as well as backing efforts to elevate China's position in international institutions, such as the International Monetary Fund. Obama administration officials have termed the new policy "strategic reassurance," which entails the U.S. government taking steps to convince China that it is not out to contain the emerging Asian power.
This was another political miscalculation on the part of Obama. The president is bound to pay a political price for it. A narrative is beginning to develop that Obama is unprincipled, and only interested in appeasing powerful people, be they bankers, insurance company executives, or the Chinese.
US sanctions and Burma's environment
This question was discussed at a recent US Senate hearing on US-Burma relations. For an overview of the hearing see, "Burma is not Vietnam." See also "Burmese slam Senate hearings" and "US Senate AWOL on Burma."
The overriding question, Sen. Webb said, is whether the current approach has brought the results we seek. Webb referred to sanctions as "tensions."
Dept. Sec. of State Kurt Campbell said that "Any easing of sanctions now would send the wrong signal to those working" to help Burma. He said that sanctions will "only be lifted if Burmese take meaningful action."
Senator Webb read from a letter from Kent M. Wiedemann, US Chargé d'Affaires ad interim for Burma (Oct 1996-May 1999). Wiedemann explained that he had frequently met with Aung San Suu Kyi, and that Suu Kyi had seen sanctions as "tactical tools." On the other hand, US based groups saw sanctions as "weapons" to force regime change. In his view, sanctions had proved harmful and counterproductive.
Sen. Webb characterizes the current approach as "unsuccessful." and cited a subsequent increase in investment into Burma by China and North Korea.
There was heated exchange between Sen. Webb and Prof. Williams, a legal scholar who opposed lifting sanctions. Williams had spoke at some length about atrocities that have been committed by the regime.
"Yes" replied Williams.
Webb said, "Vietnam in 1991 was in worse condition than Burma in 2009."
In a statement entered into the records, monk leader Ashin Candobhasacara (right) quoted with approval Sec. of State Clinton's remark, that "We will maintain our existing sanctions until we see concrete progress towards reform. But, we will be willing to discuss the easing of sanctions in response to significant actions on the part of Burma's generals that address the core human rights and democracy issues that are prohibiting Burma's progress."
Candobhasacara noted, "Sanctions help preserve the natural resources of Burma for future generations. At present, the Burmese regime is simply looting the coutnry and attempting to sell the resources to the highest bidder. The Burmese regime is not simply corrupt and skimming profits off the top of international business deals -- it is literally looting the country and keeping all the profits for itself. By placing sanctions on Burma, our country's natural resources are more likely to remain in the hands of the people so that a true representative government and market-based economy can put them to good use."
I think the environmental argument is very compelling.
However, it may be difficult to show that the pillaging of Burma's resources -- were US sanctions to be lifted -- will be appreciably worse than in other least developed countries (Laos, Cambodia, etc.). Furthermore, such "pillaging" seems bound to happen regardless in Burma. That's because Chinese investments in the country continue to expand. At least in theory, US-owned businesses can be forced to apply US environmental standards to their operations. This could impact the overall national standards. Likewise, in the labor market, in order to retain top Burmese talent, Chinese and local businesses owners may be forced to raise their standards, lest they lose them to US competitors.
Sunday, October 4, 2009
Sumatra earthquake recovery efforts
"It is interesting to note that in all three of the large earthquakes upon which I have worked ... the media has tended to initially focus their coverage upon urban areas, whilst the real story has actually been in the rural hinterland.... Thus, the disaster in these areas goes unreported for some time,... As I tell my students, in this case no news is definitely bad news...."
-David Petley, Durham University
"An experienced campaigner ... described what he saw today in the remote hills and valleys of the greater Padang area as like seeing the effects of an Atomic bomb being dropped on a huge region. He reported houses, mosques, clinics and schools flattened, and on hilly spurs, villages wiped out by landslides.
- Bob McKerrow, Red Cross and Red Crescent Society
I'm posted links to accounts of those caught up in the Padang quake, and those involved with the recover efforts -- as I get them -- here.
Saturday, October 3, 2009
China calls for release of Aung San Suu Kyi
As recently as August, China called on the West to "respect" the new detention of the Burmese opposition leader.
But today in Geneva, "China and other allies of the military government in Burma joined an international call for the release of jailed opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi." This development came in response to a Burma court verdict Friday that "rejected Suu Kyi's latest appeal for freedom." (Star h/t KMK). It coincides with moves by the US to improve its relations with Burma.
Shockingly, at this critical juncture, US senators charged with tracking developments in Burma are AWOL -- as my investigation here shows.
But today in Geneva, "China and other allies of the military government in Burma joined an international call for the release of jailed opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi." This development came in response to a Burma court verdict Friday that "rejected Suu Kyi's latest appeal for freedom." (Star h/t KMK). It coincides with moves by the US to improve its relations with Burma.
Shockingly, at this critical juncture, US senators charged with tracking developments in Burma are AWOL -- as my investigation here shows.
Delusions Exposed
If any US city deserved to host the 2016 Olympics, it was Chicago.
But a third Summer Games (LA, Atlanta...) in three decades? After US leaders snubbed world opinion for the better part of eight years? Because a popular new president spent a couple hours lobbying IOC delegates in Copenhagen? Up against an emerging world power (Brazil), on a continent (South America) that has never before hosted the Olympics?
Congratulations Rio!
___
Photo, by Jotman, shows awe-struck journalists at Obama's press conference at the London G20 summit.
But a third Summer Games (LA, Atlanta...) in three decades? After US leaders snubbed world opinion for the better part of eight years? Because a popular new president spent a couple hours lobbying IOC delegates in Copenhagen? Up against an emerging world power (Brazil), on a continent (South America) that has never before hosted the Olympics?
Congratulations Rio!
___
Photo, by Jotman, shows awe-struck journalists at Obama's press conference at the London G20 summit.
Myanmar's influence over Thai security forces
Another crackdown on Burmese dissidents in Thailand appears to be underway. The intimidation of Thailand-based Burmese groups renews old concerns about ties between Thai security forces and the wealthy junta of Myanmar. These reports pose a new challenge for Thai Prime Minsister Abhisit and Washington.
Friday, October 2, 2009
US Senate AWOL on Burma
News that a major shift is underway with regards to US policy towards Burma has coincided with reports from Amnesty International that Nyi Nyi Aung (also known as Kyaw Zaw Lwin), an American citizen, was taken prisoner by Myanmar in early September and tortured (More about that here).
Given that the Obama Administration is overturning longstanding US policy towards Burma -- and the questionable timing -- you would think that most senators on the Asian and Pacific Affairs Sub-committee of the United States Senate would have shown up at Wednesday's hearing to ask challenging questions of Assistant Sec. of State Campbell.
How many senators showed up?
Only one. (Above photo, click to enlarge.) Sen. Jim Webb, the sub-committee chairman.
Sen. Webb, a Democrat, strongly advocates engagement with Burma.
Sen. Webb did his best to chair the meeting, but one of the main purposes for holding such hearings is for the legislature to have an opportunity to hold the executive branch accountable. This is not a task for one senator alone, particularly a like-minded senator from the same party as the administration.
So I decide to investigate what other senators on the sub-committee had been doing Wednesday afternoon after 2:30pm. What was more important to the other eight senators than cross-examining Kurt Campbell (right), the American who -- "just 16 hours" previously -- had wrapped up the first high-level meeting between the US and Myanmar in many years.
ATTENDED
Democrats: Jim Webb (Virginia)
Republicans: None.
ABSENT
Democrats: Russ Feingold (Wisconsin), Barbara Boxer (California), Bob Casey (Pennsylvania), Barbara Boxer (California), Christopher Dodd (Connecticut), Kirsten Gillibrand (New York).
Republicans: James Inhofe (Oklahoma), Roger Wicker (Mississippi), John Barrasso (Wyoming)
As ranking minority member of the sub-committee, Sen. James Inhofe is the second most important member of the committee after Webb. Inhofe is responsible for notifying Republican members of the committee of the meetings. When I called Inhofe's office I was assured that Inhofe had notified the other members. When I asked why Inhofe had not attended the meeting I was told that he had to attend "an EPW press conference." I was told, "Sen. Inhofe is ranking member of the EPW."
EPW stands for Environment and Public Works. Senator Boxer (also AWOL on Burma) heads that committee, which is charged with writing the Senate climate bill. Sen. Inhofe scheduled
I am still waiting to hear back from Republican Sen. Roger Wicker's office.
The main point here is that: Two Republican members -- including Inhofe, the highest ranking Republican on the Burma committee -- decided that trashing Boxer's climate change bill took precedence over questioning a senior State Department official about a major policy shift in US-Burma relations.
Incidentally, at the "Republican Press Availability" session, when Inhofe was asked about whether he believed human activity may have contributed to global warming, Inhofe replied that he had run that question by the Oklahoma Farm Bureau:
. . . . we've asked that question of the Oklahoma Farm Bureau, and the answer is no. They -- you know, their feeling is that God is still up there. We go through cycles and there's not that strong relationship between anthropogenic gases and climate change."Attending senate hearings on foreign policy is not only about keeping the executive branch accountable, it's about being a well-informed senator. Judging by Inhofe's remarks, America desperately needs more of those.*
___
* More senators like Chuck Lugar, the soon-to-retire senator from Indiana who -- although not a member of the sub-committee -- submitted an interesting statement for the hearing record.
Thursday, October 1, 2009
Burma is not Vietnam
Live-blogging Senator Jim Webb's hearing on US-Burma relations
"Burma is not Vietnam" read the neon yellow t-shirts worn by dozens of activists.
What was the slogan supposed to mean?
"It refers to the lifting of sanctions against Burma," he said, explaining that he didn't think the arguments for lifting sanctions against Vietnam in the early '90s applied to Burma today. It was a dig at Senator Jim Webb, chairman of today's meeting. I recalled what Sen.Webb wrote in a NYT op-ed back in August:
The back of the room was packed with people sporting the neon yellow t-shirts.
At least Sen. Webb showed up for the meeting. That is more than could be said for his colleagues on the Senate Foreign Relations Sub-Committee on Burma. In the photos you can see only one seat is occupied. A veteran of senate hearings, a woman from Human Rights Watch, expressed her surprise to me about this.
How can the US senate be expected to make informed votes if members do not show up to meetings about places like Burma?
I have blogged about Burma since 2006, and if I have learned one thing, it's that its problems are not simple. They are overwhelming.
Prof. David Williams of Indiana University testified that the military commits mass atrocities against its people. It has displaced half a million.
But it was not always this way, explained Prof. David Steinberg. "In the 1940s people in Bangkok stomped to Rangoon to go shopping." He added, "Back then, anyone you shared a beer with in old Rangoon would have sworn that Burma, not Thailand or even South Korea, would be the success story."
"One man rule has meant there has been no dissent." The government had not been making informed decisions. "Arbitrary rule, based on ignorance, leads to disaster" added Steinberg.
Yet, despite its many horrors, Burma is not North Korea. Thant Myint-U pointed to religious tolerance and hundreds of NGOs as bright spots. It was also noted that unlike Laos and China, Burma permits an opposition party.
Looking to the future, Prof. Thant Myint-U worried the new generation of leaders coming up through the ranks of the military -- not having had broad experiences -- will have a narrow outlook on affairs. How to open their minds?
More to come.
___
Top photo shows two of several dozen activists who turned out for the filled-to-capacity meeting room. Middle two photos shows many empty senator-seats. Note, also, the Buddhist monks. Bottom photo shows the only senator who bothered to show up.
*****Update: I decided to investigate why so many senators didn't attend. My findings are posted here.
"Burma is not Vietnam" read the neon yellow t-shirts worn by dozens of activists.
What was the slogan supposed to mean?
"It refers to the lifting of sanctions against Burma," he said, explaining that he didn't think the arguments for lifting sanctions against Vietnam in the early '90s applied to Burma today. It was a dig at Senator Jim Webb, chairman of today's meeting. I recalled what Sen.Webb wrote in a NYT op-ed back in August:
As someone who has worked hard to build a bridge between Hanoi and America’s strongly anticommunist Vietnamese community, I believe the greatest factor in creating a more open society inside Vietnam was the removal of America’s trade embargo in 1994."A lot of people you see wearing yellow shirts helped get Webb elected" the activist continued.
At least Sen. Webb showed up for the meeting. That is more than could be said for his colleagues on the Senate Foreign Relations Sub-Committee on Burma. In the photos you can see only one seat is occupied. A veteran of senate hearings, a woman from Human Rights Watch, expressed her surprise to me about this.
How can the US senate be expected to make informed votes if members do not show up to meetings about places like Burma?
I have blogged about Burma since 2006, and if I have learned one thing, it's that its problems are not simple. They are overwhelming.
Prof. David Williams of Indiana University testified that the military commits mass atrocities against its people. It has displaced half a million.
"One man rule has meant there has been no dissent." The government had not been making informed decisions. "Arbitrary rule, based on ignorance, leads to disaster" added Steinberg.
Yet, despite its many horrors, Burma is not North Korea. Thant Myint-U pointed to religious tolerance and hundreds of NGOs as bright spots. It was also noted that unlike Laos and China, Burma permits an opposition party.
Looking to the future, Prof. Thant Myint-U worried the new generation of leaders coming up through the ranks of the military -- not having had broad experiences -- will have a narrow outlook on affairs. How to open their minds?
More to come.
___
Top photo shows two of several dozen activists who turned out for the filled-to-capacity meeting room. Middle two photos shows many empty senator-seats. Note, also, the Buddhist monks. Bottom photo shows the only senator who bothered to show up.
*****Update: I decided to investigate why so many senators didn't attend. My findings are posted here.
Wednesday, September 30, 2009
American citizen tortured by Burma, and his government is speechless
Amnesty International reports "Trusted sources have reported to Amnesty international that male [American] activist Kyaw Zaw Lwin [also known as Nyi Nyi Aung] was tortured and suffered other ill-treatment whilst in detention in Insein Prison, Yangon, Myanmar’s main city. He was arrested in Yangon on 3 September. He has been denied medical treatment for the injuries he sustained from the torture he endured during interrogation. There are grave concerns about his health."
An American citizen is tortured, and his government is speechless. Has this ever happened before? Johnathan Hulland, writing in the Huff Post, asks "why isn't there more outrage and action at this American's appalling treatment by a ruthless dictatorship? One answer is that America's recent flirtation with torture has inured it to the torture of Americans themselves, but I can't and don't want to believe this."
But it has been more than a mere "flirtation." It was US government policy. And it remains US policy to protect those who have ordered torture. And although Obama has issued a directive prohibiting torture, the new American president refuses to accord persons suspected of being terrorists with their rights under the law.
It's conceivable that the US political establishment -- Republicans and Democrats -- don't want to think about the torture of an American citizen at this time. According to Amnesty International:
Myanmar might claim that this American citizen is a "terrorist" and, following American precedent, take away any number of his rights under law. Myanmar might point to precedents set by the government of the United States -- including President Obama.
The plight of Kyaw Zaw Lwin exposes the extent to which the United States has undermined the rights of every American -- the safety of every American. Might this be what the War on Terror has come to, that the American government finds itself speechless when a brutal regime imprisons and tortures an American?
If the American government has little to say at a time like this, maybe it simply does not want Americans to hear how badly it has let them down.
An American citizen is tortured, and his government is speechless. Has this ever happened before? Johnathan Hulland, writing in the Huff Post, asks "why isn't there more outrage and action at this American's appalling treatment by a ruthless dictatorship? One answer is that America's recent flirtation with torture has inured it to the torture of Americans themselves, but I can't and don't want to believe this."
But it has been more than a mere "flirtation." It was US government policy. And it remains US policy to protect those who have ordered torture. And although Obama has issued a directive prohibiting torture, the new American president refuses to accord persons suspected of being terrorists with their rights under the law.
It's conceivable that the US political establishment -- Republicans and Democrats -- don't want to think about the torture of an American citizen at this time. According to Amnesty International:
The torture and ill-treatment that Kyaw Zaw Lwin suffered in detention included beating and kicking. He was deprived of food for seven days and moved between different interrogation centres. He was not allowed to sleep at night and was kept awake during interrogation by the authorities. Details of the charges against him are not known.Sound familiar? "Beating and kicking," "not allowed to sleep at night," "kept awake during interrogation." These are all methods of torture, prohibited under international law. But according to the way US Attorney General Eric Holder's prosecutions are supposed to proceed, nobody in a position of authority within the US government is likely to be held accountable for having ordered these very abuses against hundreds of Arab and Afghan prisoners of the US.
Myanmar might claim that this American citizen is a "terrorist" and, following American precedent, take away any number of his rights under law. Myanmar might point to precedents set by the government of the United States -- including President Obama.
The plight of Kyaw Zaw Lwin exposes the extent to which the United States has undermined the rights of every American -- the safety of every American. Might this be what the War on Terror has come to, that the American government finds itself speechless when a brutal regime imprisons and tortures an American?
If the American government has little to say at a time like this, maybe it simply does not want Americans to hear how badly it has let them down.
Burma tortures American citizen as US meetings with Myanmar begin
The titles of these Jotman blog posts give you a gist of the story.
What was the Obama Administration thinking? Why did the US remain headstrong in its determination to initiate meetings with Burma, given that it knew -- full well -- that Kyaw Zaw Lwin (also known as Nyi Nyi Aung), an American citizen, was being tortured in a jail cell in Rangoon? Why start the talks?
Timing doesn't get much worse than this.
Monday, U.S.Assistant Secretary of State Kurt Campbell said, "Let's be clear, the president's decision to approach countries with an open hand and open up a dialogue with them is a powerful tool, at least in the initial state of opening up contacts...." (my translation from the press conference video). The remark struck me when I heard it, watching a CSPAN video of the press conference. Immediately I went about transcribing the comment. I then put the quote at the top of this blog post. The Assistant Secretary seemed to be saying that the policy of engagement with Burma was happening at the initiative of the White House; and that this approach was integral to the president's approach to foreign policy (something we have known since the campaign).
The decision to open up talks with Burma had probably not been made mainly on the basis of the State Department's own analysis of the situation and its recommendations. It looks to me like a case -- of course it happened all too frequently in the past -- where a "one size fits all" policy directive is forced on the State Department. Yet another situation in which the opinions of regional experts are overlooked. (Arguably, just about every major foreign policy disaster since the Second World War can be traced back to an obstinate mindset.)
Unless Nyi Nyi Aung is released within a few days of the start of talks in New York between Assistant Secretary Campbell and U Thaung, Myanmar's minister of science, this episode could prove a disgrace for the Obama Administration.
We have every reason to suspect that Obama's overall philosophy of initiating engagement, not local contingencies seem to have driven US policy towards Burma. Realization that the Obama Administration opened negotiations with a rougue state while an American was still being tortured could compromise support for Obama's preferred approach to foreign policy. This would be a tragedy in my opinion, because even a sound and principled approach is bound to fail if the timing is wrong.
My sense is that Campbell probably knows the timing is bad -- really bad. But the State Department has been forced to engage. Perhaps the Obama Administration finds it expedient to move quickly with regards to Burma on account of some other strategy objective, perhaps concerning North Korea, China, or Iran.
In any case, I thought Campbell made it quite clear that a presidential directive was behind the overture to Burma. I thought it significant that Campbell did not credit his own boss, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton with the decision to open up talks with Burma. I would not want to be given credit for initiating these talks -- not at this time.
Whatever is going on here, Campbell will surely have some more explaining to do tomorrow. I'll try to keep you informed of developments as they happen.
UPDATE
Some further thoughts about this case: American citizen tortured by Burma, and his government is speechless
09.29 - "US to meet with Burma"
09.29 - "US citizen tortured in Burma"
What was the Obama Administration thinking? Why did the US remain headstrong in its determination to initiate meetings with Burma, given that it knew -- full well -- that Kyaw Zaw Lwin (also known as Nyi Nyi Aung), an American citizen, was being tortured in a jail cell in Rangoon? Why start the talks?
Timing doesn't get much worse than this.
Monday, U.S.Assistant Secretary of State Kurt Campbell said, "Let's be clear, the president's decision to approach countries with an open hand and open up a dialogue with them is a powerful tool, at least in the initial state of opening up contacts...." (my translation from the press conference video). The remark struck me when I heard it, watching a CSPAN video of the press conference. Immediately I went about transcribing the comment. I then put the quote at the top of this blog post. The Assistant Secretary seemed to be saying that the policy of engagement with Burma was happening at the initiative of the White House; and that this approach was integral to the president's approach to foreign policy (something we have known since the campaign).
The decision to open up talks with Burma had probably not been made mainly on the basis of the State Department's own analysis of the situation and its recommendations. It looks to me like a case -- of course it happened all too frequently in the past -- where a "one size fits all" policy directive is forced on the State Department. Yet another situation in which the opinions of regional experts are overlooked. (Arguably, just about every major foreign policy disaster since the Second World War can be traced back to an obstinate mindset.)
Unless Nyi Nyi Aung is released within a few days of the start of talks in New York between Assistant Secretary Campbell and U Thaung, Myanmar's minister of science, this episode could prove a disgrace for the Obama Administration.
We have every reason to suspect that Obama's overall philosophy of initiating engagement, not local contingencies seem to have driven US policy towards Burma. Realization that the Obama Administration opened negotiations with a rougue state while an American was still being tortured could compromise support for Obama's preferred approach to foreign policy. This would be a tragedy in my opinion, because even a sound and principled approach is bound to fail if the timing is wrong.
My sense is that Campbell probably knows the timing is bad -- really bad. But the State Department has been forced to engage. Perhaps the Obama Administration finds it expedient to move quickly with regards to Burma on account of some other strategy objective, perhaps concerning North Korea, China, or Iran.
In any case, I thought Campbell made it quite clear that a presidential directive was behind the overture to Burma. I thought it significant that Campbell did not credit his own boss, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton with the decision to open up talks with Burma. I would not want to be given credit for initiating these talks -- not at this time.
Whatever is going on here, Campbell will surely have some more explaining to do tomorrow. I'll try to keep you informed of developments as they happen.
UPDATE
Some further thoughts about this case: American citizen tortured by Burma, and his government is speechless
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
