Showing posts with label European Union. Show all posts
Showing posts with label European Union. Show all posts

Friday, March 19, 2010

Japan convinces world not to protect bluefin tuna

Not only Japanese, but also Canadians and the citizens of all but twenty nations -- should be ashamed of their governments.   Today, they failed to protect the once abundant, magnificent and endangered bluefin.

New York Times:
Delegates at a United Nations conference on endangered species in Doha, Qatar, soundly defeated American-supported proposals on Thursday to ban international trade in bluefin tuna and to protect polar bears ...
Delegates voted down the proposal to protect bluefin by 68 to 20, with 30 abstentions. The polar bear measure failed by 62 to 48, with 11 abstentions.

The rejection of the bluefin proposal was a clear victory for the Japanese government, which had vowed to go all out to stop the measure or else exempt itself from complying with it. Japan, which consumes nearly 80 percent of the bluefin catch, argued that the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas, or Iccat, should be responsible for regulating the fishery, not the United Nations. . . .
 AP reports:
Thursday's decision occurred after Japan, Canada and scores of poor nations opposed the measure on the grounds that it would devastate fishing economies.
Only the United States, Norway and Kenya supported the proposal outright. The European Union asked that implementation be delayed until May 2011 to give authorities to respond to concerns about overfishing.
The United States is certainly to be commended for its position.   No doubt US diplomats did their best, but where was the top political leadership on this issue?   The US was represented at the meeting by the assistant interior secretary for fish and wildlife and parks.  In view of the high-level commitment of the Japanese to defeat the measure, the Obama Administration does not appear to have lobbied hard enough. 

WaPo
The adult population of eastern Atlantic and Mediterranean bluefin tuna has declined 74 percent over the past half-century, much of it in the past decade, and the population has dropped 82 percent in 40 years in the western Atlantic.

"This was a case of just plain ignoring the science for short-term economic gain," said Susan Lieberman, director of international policy at the Pew Environment Group, in an interview from Doha.
Here's a terrific video of the bluefin:



Mechanisms for protecting marine species need to be improved.  Enforcement of existing restrictions against  illegal fishing is rare.  Grocery store chains and sushi joints continue to market endangered fish.  This entire issue needs to be taken more seriously by every global citizen.

AP which has produced a video on the outcome, reports that next on the agenda is protecting the sharks.  The Japanese, of course, are ready.

Thursday, June 18, 2009

How the new media revolution threatens press freedom

Some Western democracies slipped in the Index. The United States fell more than 20 places, mainly because of ... judicial action that is undermining the privacy of journalistic sources... trying to force them to disclose their confidential sources. Canada also dropped several places due to decisions that weakened source confidentiality, turning some journalists into “court auxiliaries.” France also slipped, mainly because of court-ordered searches of media offices, interrogations of journalists and the introduction of new press offenses.
- RSF, 2005

A Finnish government working group on Wednesday proposed a number of increases police powers, including the right to force reporters to name sources during the preliminary investigation stage...

...The Finnish Union of Journalists slammed the proposal as a "brazen" attack on the media.

"The protection of sources is a cornerstone of a free media," Arto Nieminen, the chairman of the union, said in a statement.
- Helsinki Times, May 20, 2009

The draft law proposed by Italian Minister of Justice Angelino Alfano ... contains provisions that restrict journalists’ right to report on police investigations, and includes heavy punishments for breaching these restrictions.
IPI, June 15, 2009

I'm thinking about a particular incident. It concerned the closing address of the IPI World Congress which was given by the Tarja Halosen, the President of Finland. (Finland will shortly take over the presidency of the European Union: so despite the small size of her country, Halosen's opinions, priorities, and positions are of no small consequence to Europe and the world).

In her talk, the Finnish president cited some new media developments as cause for concern:
There is growing concern over the violent features of the material, links and chats distributed over the Internet. Some studies show that violence on the Internet is harsher, heavier and more brutal than on television – and viewers also perceive it as more real.
The president then turned to discuss the promise of an Internet that
....opens up possibilities for civil society globally and provides a means for empowerment. It can capture people’s minds and get them involved with social change, civic action, ad hoc mobilisations, cultural experiments, the sharing of information and so on. My dream is that this positive power of media could be used to make peoples’ life and the world better.
On one hand, new media has given rise to largely speculative fears that link extremely rare but iconic events -- school shootings, abductions -- to our familiar daily interactions with the online world. On the other hand, the whole discussion of new media has given rise to some wishful thinking. So on one hand we have the fears, and on the other, the Dream. These worries and hopes are the basis for new questions that people spend more and more time debating. Can anything be more important than what happens inside our own homes or the promise of a new technology?

I think so. What Finland's president said -- and what she did not say to members of the world press assembled in Helsinki -- provides a view into how the new media revolution may pose a threat to press freedom.

Whereas fears concerning the Internet tend to be personal, the risks these times pose to journalism itself concern power relations in a society that extend beyond the individual. Issues that are not so personal. For example, how laws relate to the process of gathering news. Maybe it appears as if technological change offers the illusion of an escape not only from the stodgy old institutions of traditional media, but those problems the institutions of our free societies have evolved to confront?

But if those problems have not gone away, we are probably focusing on all the wrong questions.

What are the right questions? Since the Enlightenment, it has been generally agreed that the most important questions concerning the press concern its relation to the state. The press is the only non-governmental institution mentioned in the United States Constitution. As the president of Finland noted in her address, the press has long been regarded as a Fourth Estate, distinct from other social institutions. In short, the press has rights -- a shorthand for saying the people have the right to a free press. For example, in free countries is is agreed that -- except for certain exceptional circumstances -- journalists should have the right to protect their sources.

I disagree with the Finnish president about the dangers. The big dangers have little to do with the more offensive forms of content available on the Internet. At the same time, the promise of the Internet to make a better society remains largely speculative.

This is a time of crisis. With news organizations disappearing, the industry in disarray, a situation has arisen in which field of journalism is simply preoccupied with survival; many of the the societal structures that customarily defend the press have been disrupted.

Perhaps not coincidentally, in recent years there have even been attempts made to curtail press freedoms in Western countries. There will always be people who fervently wish the news media would just go away. By and large, those who fit this description fall into two groups: One composed of people who have wealth or power and fear losing it. The other consists of people who believe they have the ultimate truth and that nobody should be allowed -- publicly at least -- to challenge their beliefs. We are at a unique moment in history when members of either group could, with relative ease, gain the upper hand in their efforts to strangle a free press. This is the great danger of our times.

As it happens, in Finland, as the IPI delegates met, legislation was being considered that appeared to be "motivated by a desire to protect the elite from media scrutiny"according to Arto Nieminen of the FUJ.

After her address to the press delegates, Tim, an officer of the International Press Institute stood up. Tim had thought to ask the president not about her new media fears and dreams, but a question related to the age-old threat to a free press. These are my jots, based on the exchange that followed:
Timothy Spence, IPI: Confidentiality of sources is considered a foundational value of press freedom. Do you support new legislation your government is preparing that would force reporters to name sources?

President Tarja Halosen: Those persons who might be interviewed should also have protection. I hope the government will find a good balance between the two things. Even if the court says there is no reason, in the minds of the people there might be still something wrong with the person. I think when the ideas of the freedom of the person .... lets try to balance them.
Surprisingly, especially considering the context of her appearance (the meeting of a press freedom group), the president did not seem to recognize the issue she was being asked about. Tim, a seasoned newspaper reporter, tried again.
Timothy Spence, IPI: I have a follow up... My question is more is aimed at what this would do to journalists? Are you concerned that this could force the courts to release their notes?

President Tarja Halosen: I think you have to take both sides. To also think about those whose names are mentioned. I think I'm not ready to answer in detail. I would refer you to my Minister of Justice. It's always a question of balance.
In confronting the challenges posed by the Internet, we imagine all kinds of bogymen. Such were the kinds of concerns the president had come prepared to address. Of course, the media itself has played a role in stirring up such fears. Citizens naturally fear for their children, and politicians believe responding to these concerns is a high priority.

But the age-old questions? It was as if the Finnish president had forgotten about those.

At a time when the traditional news media are in crisis, we should guard against allowing enthusiasm or fears about new media to obscure genuine threats to a free press. Press freedom organizations such as IPI, RSF, or CPJ are more necessary at this time than ever before. Certainly, the age-old questions they ask have never been more timely.

Jotman live-blogged the following panel discussions at the IPI World Congress:

Monday, March 30, 2009

Confident on its path, Turkey votes

There live, blogging the election in Turkey

Tonight all over Turkey, people are glued to their television sets, checking the election results.

Turks I have spoken to say point to the economic strength of recent years as their main reason for returning the incumbent Islamic party to power. My last visit to Turkey was seven years ago -- in the spring of 2002 -- when Turkey was just coming out of a recession. Istanbul seems far more prosperous today.

One restaurant owner rattled off statistics highlighting the economic growth of Turkey during the period of my absence. He told me that:
  • turkey had gone from being the world's 25th richest country to the 15th
  • inflation was down to only 7%
  • the average annual income has climbed from $3,000 to $10,000.
I checked the last two figures with the CIA World Factbook. The restaurateur knew his figures. The article concludes: "Economic fundamentals are sound, marked by moderate economic growth and foreign direct investment." Though the latter is no doubt slowing, the people seem confident about their country's future.

What about the question of EU membership? Since I was last in Turkey, the European Union has invited numerous states to join its club - several remain less developed and democratic than Turkey. What message has Europe sent the Turks? Ahmet, a college student I spoke with -- his major was Russian literature -- provided an answer to my question.

Ahmet said, "Seven years ago attaining EU membership was all we talked about [I can vouch for that]. But today Turks' attitude is that we can make it ourselves. We don't need Europe. But Europe will someday realize it needs us."

Ahmet wished the politicians in Ankara would acknowledge this fact and stop pandering to Europeans.

Blogging tonight from Istanbul, I find it easy to imagine that an aging Europe will one day be courting the favors of a young, proud and prosperous Turkey.

Photos by Jotman.

Sunday, June 22, 2008

Thai coup bad, Burmese coup good

The night of the Thai coup of September 2006 was my entry into the world of blogging. Today Thailand stands on the brink of another coup. Street demonstrations reminiscent of the summer of 2006 seem likely to continue, perhaps to the point where the royalist-backed Thai military might once again claim cause to depose an elected government. Since the last Thai coup, I have also blogged about the desperate situation facing many Burmese. A country run for decades by an oppressive military dictatorship, Burma seems in need of a good coup.

Development expert Paul Collier, the author of a recent and important book about how the West can best advance the welfare of the "The Bottom Billion" (more here), takes up the question of "the good coup" in a WaPo op/ed. Citing the dictators in Burma and Zimbabwe as prime candidates, Collier reasons that a military coup can be a good thing. Collier is cautious, however, in making such a pronouncement:
I find it a little awkward to be writing in praise, however faint, of coups. They are unguided missiles, as likely to topple a democracy as a dictatorship. But there is still something to be said for them.
. . . as likely to topple a democracy as a dictatorship. Thailand comes immediately to mind. The Thai coup of 2006 toppled a democratically elected government; if the country were to experience yet another coup this year, it would be a crippling blow to Thai democracy. Truly, a Thai coup would be a bad coup. So how to rationalize -- legitimate -- a means of transferring power that seems anathema to the democratic ideal? Collier writes:
Since the fall of the Soviet Union, the international community has taken the rather simplistic position that armies should stay out of politics. That view is understandable but premature. Rather than trying to freeze coups out of the international system, we should try to provide them with a guidance system. In contexts such as Zimbabwe and Burma, coups should be encouraged because they are likely to lead to improved governance. (It's hard to imagine things getting much worse.) The question then becomes how to provide encouragement for some potentially helpful coups while staying within the bounds of proper international conduct.

In fact, some basic principles are not that hard to draw. For starters, governments that have crossed the red line of banning U.N. food aid -- a ghastly breach of any basic contract between the governors and the governed -- should temporarily lose international recognition of their legitimacy. Ideally, such moves should come from the United Nations itself; surely banning U.N. help constitutes a breach of rudimentary global obligations. But realistically, other dictators, worried that they might wind up in the same boat, would rally to block action at the United Nations, so we must look elsewhere.
. . . should temporarily lose international recognition of their legitimacy. Of course, Collier has Burma in mind. I agree. On 23 May I blogged:
There is no excuse for the widespread conviction that a group of criminals in uniform, men who have the audacity to call themselves "a government," must first approve before the strong, rich, and free peoples of the world go to the aid of the cyclone victims. We should be in there now, saving Burmese lives with our ships and helicopters. . . .
By turning away aid to cyclone victims, the Myanmar regime demonstrated its criminality. At such times as these a regime should not be recognized. Collier proposes a formal mechanism of international de-legitimization, which would be wonderful. At least the prospect of being "de- legitimized" serve as an incentive for a rouge regimes to behave with greater civility.

Collier reasons that UN recognition would be difficult to successfully withdraw. Therefore, he proposes that a withdraw of EU recognition might be the next best thing. Collier explains how this future mechanism of the European Union might function. Optimistically perhaps, Collier thinks the mechism could be used not just serve as a stick to keep dictators in line, but as a carrot to encourage any would-be coup plotters. Collier believes such a protocol could make good coups more likely to occur -- where and when they are most needed:
A collective E.U. withdrawal of recognition from the Mugabe or Shwe regimes would be an obvious and modest extension of the values that underpin the European project. Making any such suspension of recognition temporary -- say, for three months -- would present potential coup plotters within an army with a brief window of legitimacy. They would know that it was now or never, which could spur them to act. And even if the loss of recognition did not induce a quick coup, E.U. recognition would be restored after the three months were up.
Is fear that the outcome of a coup would not be deemed legitimate actually that which has held back potential coup-makers in the past? We don't know the answer. It seems to me there is no harm -- and much that could be gained -- were the EU to implement Collier's proposal.

__
You can read my post concerning Collier's bold ideas about development here.

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

International reaction to Tibet crisis

Here's what governments around the world are saying about Tibet. I've listed these from those comments most supportive of the Tibetans to otherwise (see Russia).

Czech: "The Czech government demands an immediate release of the detained people, and demands that they are not exposed to inhumane treatment," it said. It also urged access to the region for independent media, and the lifting of censorship.

USA: This was a smart thing to say on Condi's part:

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice reiterated on Monday her call for China to show restraint in fighting the protests and urged Beijing to find a way to engage the Dalai Lama, the exiled Tibetan spiritual leader. "There's been a kind of missed opportunity for the Chinese to engage the Dalai Lama," Rice told reporters Monday. She said the Dalai Lama is a voice of authority, not a separatist, and he could "lend his moral weight" to helping stabilize Tibet.
Taiwan: Sounds like the Tibet crisis could become a factor in the upcoming Taiwan elections.

Taiwan's ruling party presidential candidate Frank Hsieh attended a candle-light vigil Monday for Tibetans killed during China's military crackdown on unrest in the Himalayan region.

His rival Ma Ying-jeou of the opposition Kuomintang, who favours improved ties with Beijing, sent a representative to the venue.

Germany: Germany's foreign ministry said: "Everything must be done to prevent a further escalation of the situation and to enable a peaceful end to the conflict. Minister (Frank-Walter) Steinmeier calls on his Chinese counterparts to offer as much transparency as possible over the events in Tibet."

Australia: Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd said China's crackdown in Tibet was disturbing, and also called for restraint. ``While we respect China's sovereignty over Tibet there are many, many problems when it comes to human rights abuses,'' he told Australian Broadcasting Corp. radio.

UK: Rallies were held Monday in London outside the Chinese Embassy and Downing Street.

The Prime Minister insisted that violent clashes on the streets of the disputed territory must stop, and urged Beijing to resolve the situation through "dialogue".

"We have made our views known to the Chinese authority," Mr Brown told MPs. "We believe there should be restraint and an end to violence. And we believe there should be a dialogue - and that should happen soon."


EU: European Union repeated its call for "restraint on all sides".

Japan: Japan's foreign minister said: "I would like to know clearly what the situation is and the facts behind what has happened. I hope all parties involved will deal with this calmly and ensure that the number of those killed and injured does not worsen any further."

India: India is host to the Dalai Lama. His government-in-exile is based in India.

External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee said there has been no change in India's policy towards China since 1959 and that India had already expressed its concern over the developments in Lhasa. Quoting a statement issued by his ministry, he said: "We are distressed by reports of the unsettled situation and violence in Lhasa, and by the deaths of innocent people". (more here)

Russia: What to make of this?

Russia voiced support for the Chinese government over the violence in Tibet, saying it hopes "Chinese authorities will take all necessary measures to stop illegal actions and provide for the swiftest possible normalization of the situation." The Foreign Ministry said any efforts to boycott the Beijing Olympics are "unacceptable."
North Korea: condemned the riots and said protesters were trying to ``scuttle'' the Beijing Olympic Games, the official Korea Central News Agency cited the Foreign Ministry as saying. North Korea depends on aid from China after years of flooding, drought and economic mismanagement.

For IOC reactions, see this post.
___
Sources: As noted, otherwise BBC, UK Press, AP, Guardian

Saturday, January 26, 2008

The rise of the Second World

Thailand's level of development is far beyond that of neighboring Cambodia. So much so that calling both nations "developing" amounts to a grossly misleading kind of labeling. But that's how both nations routinely get described. This was a point Collier made in his recent book The Bottom Billion. Collier said the West should ask how best it may assist the poorest one billion human beings, and not lump them together with more advanced countries.

Perhaps we should refer to countries like Thailand, Brazil or Turkey as "Second World." That's the term Parag Khanna uses for them in “The Second World: Empires and Influence in the New Global Order.” An extract from his important new book appears in this Sunday's New York Times Magazine. Khanna says US global hegemony is already a thing of the past.

Khanna envisions a world with three superpowers: the US, Europe, and China. Each power competes with the other two for the allegiance of states in the Second World. The Second World, in this vision, holds the balance of power.

Blogging from Asia, it's easy to nod in agreement. From my vantage point (Bangkok), Khanna's Second World has arrived.

When Thailand's king celebrated his 80th Birthday, one guest of honor was the Defense Minister of China. Yet Thailand is an ally of the United States. Or is it? That's Thailand's ideal strategy for this new era: play China and the US off against one another. Be on good terms with both powers, but don't let either think they've won you over. An alliance between a second tier power and and a superpower is not a steady marriage in the new world order. It looks more like dating. Brazil, Turkey, South Africa, and Egypt -- to name but a few -- are other Second World powers which have already started playing the new dating game.

Khanna points to the new global economic reality. In just thirty years, global economic power has shifted three times. Until the 1980s, trans-Altlantic trade dominated, but by the 1990s the trans-Pacific trade was most consequential. Today, trade within the India-Japan-Australia triangle is greatest, according to Khanna. Most of the world's wealth is concentrated in Asia. Khanna writes:
Like Europeans, Asians are insulating themselves from America’s economic uncertainties. Under Japanese sponsorship, they plan to launch their own regional monetary fund, while China has slashed tariffs and increased loans to its Southeast Asian neighbors.
Last week at Davos, George Soros said that the financial crisis centered in the US will accelerate the divestment of Asia from the US.

Khanna's comments about China are also worth quoting as they are prescient -- China being the big new factor in the world:
The East Asian Community is but one example of how China is also too busy restoring its place as the world’s “Middle Kingdom” to be distracted by the Middle Eastern disturbances that so preoccupy the United States. In America’s own hemisphere, from Canada to Cuba to Chávez’s Venezuela, China is cutting massive resource and investment deals. Across the globe, it is deploying tens of thousands of its own engineers, aid workers, dam-builders and covert military personnel. In Africa, China is not only securing energy supplies; it is also making major strategic investments in the financial sector. The whole world is abetting China’s spectacular rise as evidenced by the ballooning share of trade in its gross domestic product — and China is exporting weapons at a rate reminiscent of the Soviet Union during the cold war, pinning America down while filling whatever power vacuums it can find. Every country in the world currently considered a rogue state by the U.S. now enjoys a diplomatic, economic or strategic lifeline from China, Iran being the most prominent example.
The main problem with Khanna's tripartite division of the world is that it would seem to pit Europe against the US. I don't see how this can happen without China emerging with a decisive advantage over the other two powers. China won't actually dictate terms to quite the extent America could in the 1990s, but by its intransigence -- by its demonstrated willingness to put trade interests before all else -- it is likely to exercise a veto-by-default over any progressive international policies of any kind. To a large extent, it already does. For example, I doubt Collier's ideas about helping the "Bottom Billion" finds quite the enthusiastic audience in Beijing as they do in London. Will China care any more about the global environment than it cares about its own poisoned countryside? Will China will put greater emphasis on human rights abroad than it does at home? Neither seems likely.

The only hope of countering China's indifference to issues of global importance will be US and European unity on the global issues of the day. To some extent, Khanna acknowledges this. One of Khanna's points of advice to the next US president is to
. . . convene a G-3 of the Big Three. But don’t set the agenda; suggest it. These are the key issues among which to make compromises and trade-offs: climate change, energy security, weapons proliferation and rogue states. Offer more Western clean technology to China in exchange for fewer weapons and lifelines for the Sudanese tyrants and the Burmese junta. And make a joint effort with the Europeans to offer massive, irresistible packages to the people of Iran, Uzbekistan and Venezuela — incentives for eventual regime change rather than fruitless sanctions. A Western change of tone could make China sweat. Superpowers have to learn to behave, too.
As I see it, either the US and Europe will learn to work together as equal partners, or shortly we will all be living in China's ravaged backyard. Unless the US and Europe largely cooperate, China's policy of trade first wins by default. Moreover, the West must inspire the emerging democracies of the Second World by its own example. In fact, if there's going to be a watchword for this new era of global diplomacy, I would say it's "leadership by example."

Yesterday's joint statement on Burma, issued by the foreign ministers of the US, France and the UK, was a small but significant step in the right direction.

Monday, December 10, 2007

Prime minister's monkey business keeps dashing hopes for progress on environmental issues

Related Links: UNFCC wikipedia, UNFCCC website, UN climate change conference in Bali website, Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) website, IPCC Fourth Assessment Report (Nov. 17, 2007 - AR4 Synthesis Report)

In the days leading up to the Bali conference on climate change, the world seemed poised to set plans in motion that would put major curbs on emissions of greenhouse gases that cause global warming. The release of major study of global warming in November* signaled the clear and present danger confronting the entire human race. Arriving in Bali last week, delegates' optimism about tackling a major environmental crisis was reminiscent of the scene at the General Assembly in New York only a year ago.

Photo (Jotman) : "Prime Minister poses for Bali photo op."

Last year at the UN headquarters, the countries of the world were poised to sign onto an extraordinary international agreement to end "bottom trawling" -- a despicable fisheries practice that effectively destroys seabed habitat. But one country was instrumental in scuttling that agreement. When this nation introduced a toothless "compromise" initiative, perhaps the last best hope for protecting undersea life on earth was sabotaged (see post).

Something eerily similar seems to be afoot this December in Bali where negotiations under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and Kyoto Protocol are being held.*

The country in question pledged a 6% CO2 reduction under the Kyoto Accord, but instead has increased its emissions by 33%. Essentially, this country signed the Kyoto Accord, but has ignored it.

As you may have guessed, the country is Canada.

BBC reports:
US opposition to the Kyoto Protocol has partly been predicated on the argument that major developing countries, as well as the industrialised world, should accept binding targets for reducing emissions.

The argument has been freshly made in Bali by Canada. A set of "Canadian Principles for a post-2012 Climate Change Agreement", leaked to environmental groups, states: "The agreement should include binding emission reduction targets for all major emitters. "

"Developed countries should be required to take action more quickly, but major industrialised developing countries should also have binding targets."

Major developing economies such as China, India and Brazil argue that their per-capita emissions are a long way below western levels, and that taking on targets would slow their economic growth.

In September the US hosted the first meeting of the "major economies" group - also known as the "big emitters" - bringing together the biggest greenhouse gas producers from the developed and developing worlds.

The same group has been meeting again on the fringes of the Bali talks, which environmental groups say is a US move designed to undermine the UN process. The US has announced a further "big emitters" summit at the end of January.

Photo (Jotman): "US President Bush hides behind Canadian Prime Minister Harper."


Opposing the Canadian block is the EU and developing countries. They want industrialized nations to start talks on a further set of emissions targets. Both sides have a valid point. Although the West brought about the climate change crisis, the rapidly industrializing East is poised to make a bad situation far worse. As Al Gore pointed out in his Nobel Peace Prize acceptance speech today, the US and China must work together to solve the problem.

The conflict is between those who argue, on the one hand that total emissions need to be the determining factor, and those who would focus on per-capita emissions. North Americans and Australians have the highest carbon emissions on a per-capita basis. The average citizen of China, for example, don't account for high emissions; but as a country, China's carbon emissions will soon surpass even America's.

Why has the EU been quick to side with the developing world?

Europeans and the Japanese have lower per-capita carbon emissions than the North Americans and Australians. They don't feel the need to own giant houses in isolated suburbs requiring long commutes. In Osaka or Rome an SUV is not considered a birthright. Basically, Europeans and Japanese don't consume as much as North Americans and Australians. The latter have perfected the high-carbon emission lifestyle. The individual inhabitants of Canada, the US, and Australia bear the largest share of responsibility for global warming on a per-capita basis. They are also among the wealthiest people on earth; their countries among the most resource-rich; and they tend to be well-educated.

Clearly, it's up these nations most responsible for a problem take the lead in solving it. Especially as the countries in question possess the skills and resources to set things right. What they lack today is leadership.

Another strategy of industrialized countries in Bali has been to turn the agenda to trade issues. Specifically, the West wants the developing countries to lower trade barriers on low-carbon energy products. Non-profit organizations are crying foul, accusing the Western block of attempting to "recycle failed WTO initiatives". Perhaps its a fair point. The World Trade Organization was set up for discussion of trade issues. And at recent talks Western industrialized countries refused to open their markets to agricultural products from poor countries, so those talks stalled.

So what's with Canada? Canada's Prime Minister, Stephen Harper is an ideological cousin of George W. Bush. On the home front, when it comes to social issues, Harper's Conservative Party is far more progressive than its American counterpart, the Republicans. But internationally, Canada's young government is rudderless; it acts as if George W. Bush were its only constituency.

Experience taught us to expect nothing by way of leadership from the former Australian Prime Minister John Howard or outgoing US President Bush. Most disappointing is the young Canadian Prime Minister.

At least the European Union and Australia's new PM Kevin Rudd are taking steps in the right direction. But it looks as if the level of international resolve and leadership necessary to tackling the climate change crisis will have to wait until after the 2008 US presidential elections.

Photo (Jotman): "President Bush returns the favor."

* The backdrop to the Bali summit is the comprehensive assessment of climate science, impacts and economics produced by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) during the course of 2007. The Bali conference is sometimes referred to as COP-13 or MOP-3
Photos: Taken at Ulu Watu Bali by Jotman. Ulu Watu is an spectacular temple situated on some high cliffs not far from Nusa Dua, the site of the UNFCCC conference in Bali.
Other sources:
UNDispatch, DeSmogBlog, BBC News

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

What happened in Burma, 8-9 October?

It's 00:00 in Bangkok (23:30 in Rangoon)

The main news of the day out of Burma is that Aung San Suu Kyi, the pro-democracy opposition leader under house arrest, turned down a proposal to meet with the government because she could not agree to the preconditions. She said: "The success of a dialogue is based on sincerity and the spirit of give and take. The will for achieving success is also crucial and there should not be any preconditions."

Senior Gen. Than Shwe had demanded that San Suu Kyi renounce her call for international sanctions against Myanmar’s government, as one precondition. (AFP) The party of Burma's detained opposition leader had urged the military junta not to set preconditions.

The man chosen by the Burmese government to liaise with detained opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi is a moderate general with a good track record of dealing with UN agencies, analysts said Tuesday. (AFP)

International Developments

- The European Union and United States want to pressure Burma's junta with the threat of sanctions. But China once again voiced its opposition. A foreign ministry spokesman told a news conference in Beijing that "sanctions or pressure will not help to solve the issue", according to The Guardian.

- In Singapore -- which does not permit gatherings of more than five people without a permit -- a group of a half-dozen demonstrators was arrested outside the presidential palace when they tried to protest the nation’s extensive trade ties with Burma’s junta. Singapore had issued unusually harsh statements against the crackdown in Burma, but critics see Singapore as more interested in protecting its investments in (AFP)