Thursday, September 17, 2009

Timeline of Rahman Bunairee's really bad summer

UPDATED Feb 2012: See below

How the US government treats friendly visitors (courageous journalists on its payroll and Nobel Peace Laureates).

Journalist Rahman Bunairee had been invited to Washington D.C. to work for a year for VOA’s Deewa Radio, the Pashto language broadcasting service to the Afghan-Pakistan border region.  Upon his arrival on American soil,  immigration officials had a surprise in store for Bunairee.  Bunairee's really bad summer was about to get even worse.

Rahman Bunairee Timeline

2006
Bunairee hired to worked as a stringer for Voice of America's Deewa Radio, which broadcasts in the Pashto language to the Pakistani-Afghan border region., also reports as a Karachi-based correspondent for Pakistan's Khyber Television." (LA Times)
2008
Five journalists killed in Pakistan according to Committee to Protect Journalists (HPost)
2009 
Apr -- - Taliban militants first marched into Buner (McClatchy)
Apr -- -  In a report for Khyber TV, Bunairee's other employer, Bunairee was critical of the Taliban assault on Buner.(McClatchy)
Jul 06 - Bunairee appears on talk show.  Taliban allege "Bunairee had spoken against the militants on Deewa Radio and criticized the security forces for not launching action in Polan." (The News, Karachi)
Jul 07 - 60 persons arrive at Bunairee's home and "politely told his family members to vacate the house as they were going to blow up the structure."  Say Taliban angry that "Bunairee had spoken against the militants on Deewa Radio"  (the News)
Jul 08 - Bunairee's house in Polan village blown up by suspected militants (BBG)
Jul 09 -  "Bunairee moves his family to Karachi, but the threats and danger persisted. There were incidents in which gunmen climbed the wall of his bureau in Karachi when he was not there." (LA  Times), The Broadcasting Board of Governors (BBG) and the Voice of America (VOA) issues second statement:  condemning  "the senseless attack on the home of VOA's Deewa Radio journalist Rahman Bunairee in Bunir, Pakistan on July 9." (KA Elliott/VOA)
Jun 12 - Another Pakistani journalist's house gets blown up.  Behroz Khan "became the second journalist whose house was destroyed by suspected Taleban militants in Buner in recent days." (BBC Monitoring)
Jul 17 -  "Asked about his take on the situation in Malakand division since the government has announced it was now safe, and internally displaced people (IDPs) are being shifted there, Bunairee said: "The fire that engulfed Malakand division has not been extinguished as yet, and I believe the war will continue for decades." (INSI)
Jul (late) - Bunairee "staying in a guest house and maintaining a very low profile"
Jul 30 - Immigration at Dulles International airport  detains Nobel Peace Laureate Mairead Maguire in a special processing area over two hours causing her to miss her connecting flight to Albuquerque (Ten Percent):
... when she told the U.S. Immigration Officer at Dulles airport that she was a Nobel Peace Laureate and showed him the documents concerning the Peace Laureate meeting she was attending in New Mexico, the Immigration Officer sarcastically said that detention “is going to happen every time you enter the United States,” and “you should get used to it.”
Aug 09 - Journalist Rahman Bunairee arrives at Washington Dulles International Airport with "a valid U.S. visa (visa issued by the U.S. Embassy in Islamabad) and ample documentation of his sponsorship for a yearlong exchange program for the Voice of America, a U.S. government agency. (WaPo)
--- -- - Customs and Border Protection officials interrogate Bunairee, rejected his visa, label him an 'intending immigrant' and threatened to deport him.  
--- --  - sent to jail in Hampton Roads, Va.
Aug 10 - Bunairee in jail (WaPo)
Aug 11 - Bunairee in jail (WaPo)
Aug 12 - Bunairee in jail, exhaustive legal efforts by the State Department to obtain his release. (WaPo)
Aug 13 - Bunairee in jail, exhaustive legal efforts by the State Department to obtain his release. (WaPo)
Aug 14 - Bunairee in jail, exhaustive legal efforts by the State Department to obtain his release. (WaPo), VOA Statement on "detention of stringer"
Aug 15 - Bunairee in jail, exhaustive legal efforts by the State Department to obtain his release. (WaPo), LA Times story published
Aug 16 - Bunairee in jail, exhaustive legal efforts by the State Department to obtain his release (WaPo),  Immigration officials question Bunairee "for about 20 minutes to determine whether he has the required 'credible fear' of returning" (McClatchy) [Jotman comment: WTF?]
Aug 17 - Bunairee in jail, exhaustive legal efforts by the State Department to obtain his release. (WaPo)
Aug 18 - Bunairee in jail, exhaustive legal efforts by the State Department to obtain his release. (WaPo), McClatchy story published
Aug 19 - U.S. authorities free Bunairee under terms that forbid him to work.  Terms of his release also bar VOA from giving him any money, VOA's parent agency, the Broadcasting Board of Governors, issued a statement welcoming Bunairee's release, describing him as a man of extraordinary courage and dedication. (Dawn, Pakistan).
Aug 20 - Living off of charitable contributions. (WaPo)
Sept 15 - D. Jeffrey Hirschberg, a member of the Broadcasting Board of Governors, writes in a  WaPo Op/Ed:
Rahman Bunairee works for Deewa Radio, the VOA's Pashto-language service targeted to the troubled Afghanistan-Pakistan border region. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has said that "we are being out-communicated by the Taliban and al-Qaeda" in the area, a circumstance she called "absolutely unacceptable." The U.S. envoy for the region, Richard Holbrooke, has argued that Taliban propaganda "is key to the insurgency's terror campaign" and that it must be countered. 
Recognizing the value of Deewa's contribution, Congress increased its funding early this summer to expand broadcasts. This means Deewa will need to attract more experienced journalists, including some from Pakistan, and quickly. 
If the Taliban were in charge of America's borders, wouldn't they have wanted to see Bunairee denied entry into the United States, and be treated like some kind of criminal?   

The Economic Times explains the paperwork confusion that apparently led to Rahman Bunairee's 10-day detainment.  But you don't put someone in jail for not having every piece of paper in perfect order.  Immigration law blogger Siskind asked: "I am left wondering why the State Department didn't just arrange with DHS to have Bunairee paroled in to the US in order to apply for asylum rather than going the J-1 route."  Good question.

Whatever one's views of the merit of the American military effort in Afghanistan, anyone can see that exposing Central Asians to quality journalism and the world of ideas is among the most constructive ways Western countries can engage the people of the region.  Moreover, compared the cost of planes, bombs, and soldiers, Voice of America is not expensive.  VOA is doing good work around the world. For example, blogging from inside Burma, I documented the important role Voice of America has played in helping to keep the Burmese people informed. 

But the story of Rahman Bunairee's really bad summer has a meaning that extends beyond the obvious importance of Bunairee's work, and the need for Voice of America. 

If this is the way the America treats foreigners who work for the US government, it really makes you wonder how America treats other friendly visitors -- friends who don't arrive on America's shores at the invitation of a US government agency.  The answer is alarming.  Many well-traveled non-Americans can tell you a "horror story."  Not only Pakistanis, but also Indonesians, Austrians, Italians, even Icelanders.  Even winners of  US government Fulbright scholarships have not been admitted.  Such stories not only make for lousy PR, the policies that give rise to them are bad for business.

US detention laws are such that travel to the former USSR probably posed far fewer risks for good law-abiding foreigners than a routine visit to the United States does today.  And the fate of the Soviet Union shows that once a country closes its borders to the world, its days of influence are numbered.

Update (Feb 2012): In May 2010 Rahman Bunairee received the David Burke Distinguished Journalism Award from VOA for his "daring and thought-provoking broadcasts."  The award cited "his reporting on the 2009 clashes between Pakistani troops and militants in Pakistan's tribal areas."   A VOA article describing his award states that "Bunairee fled to the United States after militants, apparently angered by his coverage, set off a bomb at his family home and threatened him." 

Rahman Bunairee now lives with his family in Washington D.C.. 

Wednesday, September 16, 2009

Spirits on the Mall


Apart from color correction, no photo manipulation. If the spots were not added to the image, where did they come from? More spirit photos here.

Words are free

President Obama, in a speech to the nation's bankers:
"Hear my words: We will not go back to the days of reckless behavior and unchecked excess at the heart of this crisis. Those on Wall Street cannot resume taking risks without regard for consequences, and expect that next time, American taxpayers will be there to break their fall."
Yeah, sure. 

Sunday's pro-health care reform rally in Washington

 
How many Obama supporters showed up to rally for health care reform?

On Sunday September 14, 2009, the day after an estimated 75,000 people marched on the US capital to protest Obama, supporters of health care reform held their own rally.   The above photo gives you some indication of the size of the turnout.

It occurs to me that the Obama Administration is being managed by "bean counters."  The president behaves as if his strategists have carefully weighed how much each and every policy will cost Democrats in terms of future donations from this industry lobby or that one. The result?  Uninspired policies, unmotivated supporters, poorly-attended rallies.

What's true for a growing business must be equally so for a rising political movement.  Obama ought to fire his bean-counters before it's too late.

Where was this crowd?

I'm starting to  feel embarrassed for Democrats who walk around holding pictures of President Obama.  But I feel a lot more embarrassed for the tea-baggers.

It's as if the Fox News orchestrated tea-bag movement that swarmed Washington Saturday had never heard of "saving for a rainy day."  During the Bush years Americans didn't save enough.  Their government didn't save enough.

Then it rained.  Hard. To stay dry the government sought to stimulate the economy (to avert a possible great depression, more job losses, deflation, a "lost decade" such as Japan experienced during the 1990s.) Emergency spending further increased the deficit. Mainly because the kitty was already empty.

Increased government spending during a major economic downturn is defensible. Anyone can justify it.

But for the US government to have over-spent during boom years -- during a time of escalating liabilities (war, an aging population) -- was not defensible.   We can debate emergency economic relief measures until our faces turn blue. But giving the wealthy tax cuts during boom years and yet making no effort to balance the deficit was just plain irresponsible. Grossly irresponsible.  Especially given that the country was fighting two wars.

The most anger should be directed at the group that emptied the kitty, not the leader forced to confront an economic meltdown on an empty kitty.

Have you noticed that they only call it socialism when it comes to spending taxpayer money in such a way that ordinary taxpayers might benefit?  It's interesting that the Fox News crowd has been relatively quiet about corporate socialism: bailing out Wall Street, give-aways to the pharmaceutical industry, continued investment in the military hardware needed to fight the Soviets, the wars of choice.

To imagine that 46 million Americans don't have any health insurance, yet everyone else in the developed world has coverage; that only Americans stand to lose their health insurance when they get downsized; or stand to lose their homes if they come down with a severe chronic illness.

It all makes you feel kind of embarrassed for them, doesn't it?

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Inventor of Segway aims to solve actual problem

The Segway symbolizes everything that is wrong with the American economy.

As the tech bubble was bursting, one of the cleverest inventors in the land, backed by A-list Silicon Valley investors, set out to produce a top secret device that would "change the world as we know it."

The result -- we now know -- was a machine that serves as a substitute for foot or bicycle as means of transportation.

Knowingly or not, Dean Kamen and his flock of investors had set out to solve America's "walking problem."   In addition,  they also appeared set on solving the "bicycling problem."   (Everyone knows Americans spend far too much time walking and bicycling.)

The Segway  only adds 80 lbs and  $4,300 to the price of a quality  bicycle.  But on a Segway you have your hands free (almost), so arguably the Segway is more comparable to walking, except that you don't get any exercise.  

The Segway can best be compared to the unicycle.   It even looks a bit like one.

Of course, a unicycle weighs less, and costs even less than a good bike (one wheel being less expensive than two).*  One difference is that it takes about eight hours of practice before you can ride anywhere on a unicycle; and it will take another eight hours of practice before you can navigate various obstacles. I speak from experience, have taught more than a dozen people to ride a unicycle. On the other hand, a Segway can be mastered in under an hour.  My advice to anyone serious about investing in a Segway is to pay themselves $281.25 an hour for the 16 hours it will take them to learn to get around on a unicycle.

Unlike buying a Segway, acquiring unicycle skills is an investment -- one that will pay compounded dividends over time. Not only in terms of your health.  As your unicycling skills improve over time, you will be able to go places on your unicycle -- up hills, down stairs, over bumps -- where no Segway will ever go.  (Again, I speak from experience. I was among the first practitioners of a sport that has come to be known as "mountain unicycling."  Try that on a Segway.)

Unbelievably, American investors pumped an estimated $100 million into developing the Segway. In so far as the Segway is just another expensive solution to a non-existent problem, the Segway is the perfect symbol for  everything that is wrong with American economy.

As silly as the Segway debacle may be, America's giant pharmaceuticals and its military-industrial complex have wasted hundreds of billions of dollars attempting attempting to solve equally irrelevant problems.   Like pursuing a mass-market for the Segway, ensuring the continued growth of big pharmaceutical firms or arms-manufacturers requires the American public to abandon some less-expensive, time-tested, tried-and-true alternative strategies for better marketed ones:  People must be encouraged to forsake tasty natural foods and exercise, and instead pop pills while they super-size their fast food; someone must convince them diplomacy is for wimps.

What important problem was the financial industry trying to solve when it invented mortgage-backed derivatives?

The lamest innovations have always led to new, unforeseen problems.  The Iraq War, the Viox recall debacle, are but the most visible side-effects of America's most egregious bad investments.  Even the Segway has had unwanted side-effects: As Segways proliferate at popular American sight-seeing venues, one can no longer walk down some sidewalks without fearing collision with a very large body traveling at a high velocity on a rental.  Worse may be yet to come.

CNN reports (h/t J-P) Segway inventor Kamen has a new vision.  This time Kamen is proposing to solve an actual problem.  Namely,  the shortage of clean drinking water which afflicts many parts of the developing world.  Kamen calls his new invention the Slingshot.

Of course, the lack of fresh drinking water that plagues many poverty-stricken areas of the world -- or malaria, another major killer -- is not a new problem. 

Had American inventors and their bankers not been so preoccupied with solving non-problems,  many real-world problems would have been solved by now.
___
Photos by Jotman.
* Before you blow $4,500 on a new Segway, check out your other options at Unicycles.com.

Monday, September 14, 2009

Ethiopians demand Washington end support for Meles Zenawi

One thousand Ethiopians marched from the White House to Capitol Hill Sunday. They urged Obama to reconsider US support for the Ethiopian regime. They came from across the US and Canada, representing various ethic groups -- many of which have seldom worked together toward a common goal.

Increasingly, Ethiopians blame the Ethiopian government for fomenting bloody ethnic conflict. They also blame the regime for political repression and extrajudicial killings.  Over the past 18 years that Prime Minister Meles Zenawi has been at the helm of the ruling Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF), human rights groups have documented war crimes; unlawful detention, torture, rape, and ethnic killings have been committed by the security forces.

The outrage over human rights abuses mounts at time of heightened US support for the Ethiopian government.  The country has been viewed as an important US ally in the Horn of Africa for the Global War on Terror.   In December 2006 the US supported the Ethiopians when they invaded Somalia and crushed the Islamic Courts Union.  Earlier I reported my conversation with a Somali taxi driver:
It was his view that Somali warlords just had to say, “Hey CIA, we’re fighting Al Qaeda” and they got all the support they needed.
It worked the same way during the Cold War.  Inevitably wrong choices got made, empowering the likes of Saddam Hussein and Bin Laden. 
 

On the lawn in front of the Congress, organizers asked attendees to sign letters to Congressmen. The letters  called upon Congress to withdrawal taxpayer support for the regime; demand the release of prisoners of conscience such as Mrs. Birtukan Mideksa, Chairwoman of Unity for Democracy and Justice party (UDJ); and demand that the regime respect human rights.

Sunday's demonstration was organized by the Solidarity Movement for a New Ethiopia, a new group  recently founded by Obang Metho (interview).  Metho became an actist following the December 13, 2003 massacre in the Western province of Gambella.  Some 124 Anuaks were allegedly killed within a three day period by government forces.

"Ethiopia is a country, not a tribe" read one protester's sign -- a moto which captured the spirit of this unique event.

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Nicholas Sarkozy: tax carbon at the border


FT (via Krugman) reports on a proposal from French President Sarkozy:
“I will not accept a system ... that imports products from countries that don’t respect the rules [on carbon emission reductions],” he said in a speech to factory workers in the eastern Ain region of France.

“We need to impose a carbon tax at [Europe’s] borders. I will lead that battle.”

The French president has in the past sparked accusations of protectionism after calling for European import tariffs on products from countries that do not abide by international targets on carbon emission reductions.

On Thursday economists warned that such an initiative – likely to be supported by some European countries such as Italy – could have catastrophic consequences for the ongoing attempts to strike a global trade deal.

“This would put the developed world on a collision course with China, India and other developing countries. It could do serious damage to the international trade system,” said Simon Tilford, chief economist of the Centre for European reform. “It would be seen as naked protectionism.”

Mr Sarkozy sought to defend his position, which is clearly aimed at making France’s own carbon tax more palatable in the face of strong public opposition.

“A carbon tax at the border is the natural complement to a domestic carbon tax. More importantly, a carbon tax at the borders is vital for our industries and our jobs. This has nothing to do with protectionism,” he said. “This is about fair play.”
In a previous post I said I thought it would be better only to threaten a border carbon tax after the failure of the Copenhagen meeting on  climate change.    My feeling is that it would be much better if you could convince  polluting countries to impose the carbon tax themselves. That way, they could use the money to pay for investment in non-polluting technologies.

Nevertheless, to make a  domestic carbon tax palatable to impatient domestic constituencies, Sarkozy and members of the US Congress are already talking about punishing countries that don't do enough to reduce their own carbon emissions.  The principle of a border tax, as economist Stiglitz -- and now Krugman -- explain, is fair.  To me, it is the timing of the French and American proposals that is questionable. 

But on second thought, might there be an argument to be made that it would actually be preferable for carbon to be taxed mainly at the border?  Perhaps.  

Understandably, the developing world has demanded that the West pay for the cost of going carbon neutral.  I live-blogged Shell chairman Ollila (photo right) telling an audience in Helsinki that on moral grounds, there's no bucking the developing world's insistence on this point:
Developed economies have used up the atmosphere's capacity to absorb CO2; now developing countries are entering a phase where their need for energy is becoming intensive.

In addition to policy angle, there is a geopolitical angle: significant change with regards to emerging markets. Advanced economies must lead by example. This will necessitate resource transfers from developing to emerging markets. But transfers from govt to govt are problematic. Consider the position of a US political leader who proposed such a transfer. He would face political problems.
Cap and trade is a politically feasible way to make the transfers. CDM is a license to do arbitrage -- create opportunities between developed and developing economies.
If there is no straightforward global Cap and Trade deal,  might border-levied carbon taxes achieve something similar?   Supposing rich countries levy taxes on imports from developing countries, theoretically these taxes could be returned to developing countries.*   To the extent there is less corruption in rich countries, at least this way everyone would know that a carbon tax is actually being levied.   Also, this way it may be possible to ensure that more of the tax actually went towards subsidizing alternative energy projects in the developing world.

Nevertheless, in a 2008 paper on "border carbon adjustments" (Pdf), Aaron Cosbey wrote that "there may be an inherent tension between administrative feasibility on the one hand, and effectiveness or WTO legality on the other."   In terms of effectiveness, Cosbey suggests that "a broader scheme will be particularly difficult to manage, but a scheme that is more narrowly cast may have unintended adverse impacts."

Moreover, the bulk of China's future carbon emissions will likely not be produced on account of the goods China manufactures for export, but as a by-product of production for local consumption.

In the long run, I wonder if a border carbon border tax would concern a sufficiently large segment of the global economy to make a difference.  On the other hand, maybe getting global industry** on the right track will require some short-term prodding. 

Is Sarkozy on the right track?  Taking into account factors like national pride (i.e. the cultural sensitivity factor), the imperialistic history of France and, more recently, the arrogance of American leaders, I think it is surely better not to go there yet -- not even talk about going there -- unless we have to.  But if no global deal emerges from Copenhagen, it's good to have this alternative strategy in mind.
___
Photo of Sarkozy by Jotman was taken at the G20 in London.
*  Returning this money is apparently not envisioned by the bill before the US Congress. According to the CTC, in "Rep. John Larson’s new carbon tax bill . . . U.S. would collect and retain the revenue generated by equalizing carbon taxes on products imported from countries that haven’t enacted their own or whose carbon tax rate is lower than ours."  A paper by Aaron Cosbey shows that there are various ways to implement "border carbon adjustments" (Pdf here, excerpt here).
** Global industry or countries?  Just a thought: Perhaps rather than thinking about border carbon taxes in terms of  "developed countries Vs developing countries" we should think in terms of a global system dominated by a relatively small number of large corporations.   

Friday, September 11, 2009

Poverty's way up in America

WaPo reports on the growing number of invisible Americans (I call them "invisible" because you hardly hear anything about them on television, and few US politicians are taking this problem seriously):
A new comprehensive economic survey shows that the recession has plunged 2.6 million more Americans into poverty, wiped out the household income gains of an entire decade and pushed the number of people without health insurance up to 46.3 million. 
President Obama is absolutely committed to making it possible for many more Americans -- but not everybody -- to have access to heath insurance.   It seems as if politicians never have to worry about everybody these days.

Will Dmitry Medvedev's Gazeta article move Russia forward?

Which way is Russia headed? Three interesting developments in Russia over the past week have led to new -- and quite contradictory -- speculation.

First, a new history textbook released this fall presents Stalin in a more favorable light.  A Moscow historian told the National Post that in the past "Soviet textbooks hid what had happened.  But now Stalin's terror is presented as not only necessary but useful."    The newspaper article lists some other recent initiatives  that make it sound as if Stalin is being resurrected as a national hero.

However, not all recent developments are so ominous.

The Russian Education Ministry said Wednesday that excerpts of Alexander Solzhenitsyn's The Gulag Archipelago are to be required reading for students. (AP)  In addition to being a severe critic of Soviet-style communism,  Solzhenitsyn, who died last year, was passionate about self-government on the model of New England and Switzerland, held a romantic view of Russian history, and was a harsh critic of the commercial culture of the West.

Finally, Russian JOTMAN.COM contributor Sanjuro reports on an interesting development that has not yet been reported in the Western media:
President Dmitry Medvedev's program article "Russia, forward!" has just been published in the Gazeta.ru  - a not very obvious choice for a Russian president, as the Gazeta has increasingly been in liberal opposition.

It's mostly about overcoming corruption and technological backwardness. Ironically, the tone is evocative of the Stalin's famous call for defence of the Motherland back in 1941 ("My dear compatriots! Brother and Sisters!..."). It has already generated over 800 responses from the Gazeta.ru readers and counting... Many responses are skeptical, some plainly write they believe neither Medvedev, not Putin. There are some hopeful ones, but I had the impression that most readers were deeply suspicious of any attempts from the authorities to restore the feedback channel.
Sanjuro points to this state media report which summarizes points raised by the Russian president in the article:
In his article entitled “Russia, Forward!” published on the Gazeta-Ru” website, the head of state mentions among such ailments, above all, “the age-old economic backwardness, persistent reliance on the export of raw materials in exchange for finished products.” He notes, “These elements of the innovation system were created, not without success, by Peter the Great, by the last czars and by the Bolsheviks.” However, “too steep a price was paid for those successes. They were usually achieved by inordinate exertion, at the limit of the potential of the totalitarian state machine.

Another ailment, Medvedev notes, is “the age-old corruption depleting Russia from the times immemorial and eroding to this day the economic area and other areas of public activity of any importance because of the excessive interference of the state.”
The point of the matter “is not only the excessive presence of the state. Business is not without fault, either.” Many business people, the president notes, instead of looking for talented inventors, introducing unique technologies, producing and putting new products on the market, aim for bribing officials to get the “control of the flows” of property redistribution
According to Sanjuro, indications are that Medvedev's initiative was aimed at Russians, and not something he carried out with the intention of impressing the international community.

Which way is Russia headed?  Given all the mixed signals from the government these days, even the Russians are puzzled.
___
In June 2009, Jotman traveled to Helsinki to discover the answer to the question: What kind of bear is Russia?

Thursday, September 10, 2009

Rep. Joe Wilson shouts "You lie!" at President Obama

2 UPDATES

NY Times:
In an angry and very audible outburst, Representative Joe Wilson, Republican of South Carolina, interrupted President Obama’s speech Wednesday night with a shout of “You lie!”

His eruption — in response to Mr. Obama’s statement that Democratic health proposals would not cover illegal immigrants — stunned members of both parties in the House chamber.
In my live-blog of the speech, I referred to the associated outburst as "an odious spectacle. Disgusting" --  although at the time I could not make out the words.  It was the loud jeering at the mere mention of the phrase "illegal immigrants" that I found disturbing.   I imagine this kind of spectacle must have unfolded on the floor of the old Reichstag before the fire.

After the speech Rahm Emanuel said: “No president has ever been treated like that. Ever.”

Update 1 (Saturday)

Several thousand Thousands and thousands of Fox News viewers -- they call themselves "tea party" demonstrators -- held a rally in Washington D.C. Saturday.   They seemed to be against a lot of things: Obama, health care reform, government, taxes, etc. One guy many of the demonstrators seemed to admire was Rep. Joe Wilson (see this post for background).

A group of young Joe Wilson supporters (two are pictured in the photo above) were standing outside the White House when an old lady started shouting at them.

"You boys are just like the people who ruined Europe in the 1930s!" she said.  

Tourists looked on bemused.  These kids didn't look particularly ominous in their penny loafers.  No, it wasn't the shirts that I found troubling.  It was the realization that the guys in the baby blue "Joe Wilson" shirts probably had no clue about the events the old lady was referring to.

These days, ignorance about the world and its history is disconcerting.

Update 2 (Monday)

Raven (see comments) suggets that the estimate I first reported above was too low.  I agree. I arrived too late to get an idea of the crowd size Saturday.  Estimates of the numbers range from 3,000 (one news source) to "tens of thousands" (I saw this figure at NY Times, Department of Homeland Security, Fox News). Because I saw so few stragglers, I assumed the correct number was the lower one.  But on Sunday several Obama supporters who had watched the tea party protesters march told me there were "about 15,000."  They said, "metros stations were  full of demonstrators Sunday."   Some sources claim protesters numbered in the hundreds of thousands.

We did not come here to fear the future, we came here to shape it

Live-blogging Obama's address to Congress on health care reform.

I'm watching the president give his address on CNN.    Obama's remarks in bold; my comments in regular font.   Pelosi introduces Obama.

Thank you.   When I spoke last winter, worst economic crisis losing 700,000 jobs a month.   Still losing jobs.  I will not let up until those Americans who seek jobs can find them.  He has got his priorities straight.  Until businesses that seek capital  can thrive, until all responsible homeowners can stay in their homes.   And those responsible bankers?  Silence on that point.

. . . .  It has now been nearly a century since T. Roosevelt called for health care reform.   (Gives history....)  Americans -- middle class -- one accident away from losing home; many denied by insurance companies; We are the only Advanced Democracy that allows such hardship for its citizens.    30 million affected.  Not just problem for uninsured.  Worry that if you change your job you will lose coverage.   Happens every day.    One man lost coverage in the middle of chemotherapy when coverage canceled.  Died.  A  breast cancer patient had her coverage denied (for silly reason).   This is good.   He's reminding people of the horror stories.

Insurance premiums have gone up 3 times faster than wages.  If  we do nothing, will end up spending more on healthcare than any other govt program.

Question is how?  Those on left, think only way is to have system-wide (universal) coverage.  On the right, end employer based systems, leave individuals.  Either one would represent a radical shift.  Makes  more sense to  build on  what works.   This is classic "Obama Philosophy," but it's notable that Obama has framed the arguments more favorably for the left than he had earlier in August.   This time he equated the the "far left" with Universal Coverage.  Back in August Obama had equated those favoring the Public Option with the far left.  Yet the public option is a fairly centrist position, a compromise -- at least from the perspective of anyone who favors Universal Coverage.  

Nothing in this plan will require you or your employer to change existing coverage. What plan will do:  "As soon as I sign this bill, it will be against the law for insurance companies to drop your coverage when you get sick or water it down when you need it most."  

"No one should go broke because they get sick."

"If you lose your job or change your job, you will be able to get coverage," Obama will say. "If you strike out on your own and start a small business, you will be able to get coverage."  "Strike out on your own to start a small business, you can get coverage."

Speaking to those who don't already have coverage, Obama will say his plan calls for a new "insurance exchange," to allow individuals in small business to shop for health insurance at competitive rates.  A brilliant idea?  A new trading scheme people in the financial industry will profit from?  Details.

We pay for emergency room visits anyway.... 

 You will be required to carry basic health insurance, just like auto insurance.   Businesses will be required to offer it, or chip in to help Americans cover it.   I don't like this at all.   Still nothing about a public option, and requirement to buy insurance industry's products.

While still details to get worked out.  (Laughter).  Requirement for those who can afford insurance to get coverage. 

Obama adresses myths.  "Reforms would not apply to those who are here illegally"  (Hooting from audience.)  Odious spectacle. Disgusting. "Government take-over of entire health care system....?"  "Let me set the record straight: consumers do better when there is choice and competition."  Unfortunately in 34 states (little competition) so incentive to abuse customers.  "Executives don't do this because bad people, they do it because it is profitable." Key point, it's the profit-motive that's inherent in the system, not greedy individuals.

The reforms that I've just mentioned would do that, but an addition measure that would do that would be a not-for-profit public option.  Loud applause from Democrats.   Only an option for uninsured, not mandatory.   Taxpayers won't subsidize this.  Has to be self-sufficient, relying on premiums it collects.   Avoids overhead and need to make profit, so could be good deal for consumers.   Just as we have public universities and private universities, we can have the public and private options coexist in health care.  This is a great slogan, I'm glad he used it.  Still neither side should over-emphasize the importance of the public option.  OK up until this point, then why must he start to equivocate?   Obama would preserve his freedom to drop the public option.   Essentially, Obama calls stuff that's important to a lot of Democrats not that important.    Republicans don't use this language when talking about points that are important to the base.

I will not back down on the basic principle that if you cannot find coverage, we will provide you with a choice.  Good!  Very strong!  Finally Obama draws a line in the sand.   And make sure no insurance ?? gets between you and the coverage you need.

Iwill not sign it if it adds one dime to the deficit, now or in the future.   Obama mentions that during the Bush era, wars  and tax cuts were not paid for.   I'm glad he pointed this out.

Seniors need not worry.  Notes that seniors have been subjected to campaign of lies and distortions.  We won't use Medicare funds to pay for this new program. Don't pay attention to those people scaring you, some of whom wanted to privatize medicare.  Don't worry, I will protect medicare."

Will help bring down the costs of healthcare. 

Now this is the plan I'm proposing.  If you come to me with serious proposals, my door is open, but I won't waste time with people who say it's better politics to kill plan than keep it.  Mainly a threat directed at Democrats threatening not to back a plan that doesn't include the public option?  Or mainly a threat to blue dogs who don't want a public option? If you misrepresent what's in this plan, we will call you out.  (Applause) I will not accept status-quo as a solution.

Quotes Ted Kennedy:  ".... The character of our country."  Self-reliance, fierce defense of freedom,  figuring out proper role of government always central.   Repubs. John McCain, Owen Hatch worked with Kennedy to provide care to the weak; Kennedy had 2 kids with cancer, so could imagine what like to not have insurance.  Good story.  This concern for the plight of other is not a Democrat or a Republican trait.  An acknowledgment that sometimes government has to step in.  Social Security.  Medicare.  Medicaid.   Monopolies can stifle competition. 

When any efforts to help people in need attacked; when we can't have civil debate, that's the worst thing. Great line, I should get the exact quote. 

Update, here is the exact wording of this passage which reads so true (from here):
And they knew that when any government measure, no matter how carefully crafted or beneficial, is subject to scorn; when any efforts to help people in need are attacked as un-American; when facts and reason are thrown overboard and only timidity passes for wisdom, and we can no longer even engage in a civil conversation with each other over the things that truly matter that at that point we don't merely lose our capacity to solve big challenges. We lose something essential about ourselves.
"We did not come here to fear the future, we came here to shape it."  Great line.*   I still believe we can ....  That is our calling...  That is our character.

The strength of Obama's speech was that he did not make it make it mainly about cutting costs.  (I'm listening to the Republican response, and that's their main point).

Obama delivered a speech that was largely about values.  Obama presented an expanded vision of American values; it includes concern for others, it affirms a constructive role for government in protecting the weak and ensuring fairness.  Obama explained that this tradition is as much a part of American heritage as free enterprise and individualism. By aligning his health care initiative with American values, Obama may have successfully shifted the discussion tonight from one that had been mainly about people's fears to one centered on peoples' hopes and aspirations.  Obama was also correct to warn the country about the dangers of allowing intolerance and negativity to poison the debate.  Although we don't know what will come of this approach, it matters that Obama has attempted to re-frame the discussion.

Some past posts about the US health care debate:
___
*  "We did not come here to fear the future, we came here to shape it." Others have commented on this line as well, and it may give rise to yet another right-wing conspiracy theory about Obama. "Glenn Beck [outrageous Fox News commentator] will love this" noted BBC's Mark Mandell referring to the line in his own live-blog.  Ali Eteraz of True Slant explains the Karl Marx reference:
  ... to me, at the end of his healthcare speech, Obama just evoked one of the most famous of Karl Marx’s phrases. . . . Sayeth Marx in Theses on Feurebach: 'The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point is to change it.'  Again, not equating Obama with socialism — that would be foolish — but the linguistic formulation is similar, especially because when Obama verbalized those two sentences he said them as if there were a semi-colon between them, not a period.   
As you can see from my own jot, I heard it with a comma.  Nevertheless, the Obama line does not strike me as sounding particularly similar to the Marx quotation.  Of course,  if it's possible to spin it that "Obama was channeling Karl Marx," someone at Fox News is sure to run with it.  (Speaking of which, I just watched Hannity of Fox News say to a guest on his program: "What do you think about the fact Obama called insurance company CEOs 'bad people' in his speech?"  Actually, Obama said the exact opposite:  "Executives don't do this because they are bad people, they do it because it is profitable.")

Update: In his July 4th radio address the president said, "We are not a people who fear the future. We are a people who make it."

Tuesday, September 8, 2009

Van Jones and the new McCarthyism

Van Jones "was appointed by President Barack Obama in March 2009, to the newly-created position on the White House Council on Environmental Quality."

But late last week the Obama Administration appeared to have dumped him.  This happened after Glenn Beck of Fox News waged a relentless smear campaign against Van Jones.  Eventually Fox dug up a couple facts that seemed to stick. WaPo reports them:
Jones issued two public apologies in recent days, one for signing a petition that questioned whether Bush administration officials "may indeed have deliberately allowed 9/11 to happen, perhaps as a pretext for war" and the other for using a crude term to describe Republicans in a speech he gave before joining the administration.
The attacks of 9/11 angered almost everyone and the response of the Bush Administration to the crisis also angered many people.  This led many Americans to entertain conspiracy theories -- a 2006 poll showed that 35% of Democrats believed Bush knew of the 9/11 attacks in advance.

It was like déjà vu.  Some Americans responded similarly to the unsettling early decades of the 20th Century: Observing growing inequality and social injustice and seeking a coherent narrative, people explored what could be described as the "greatest conspiracy theory of all time."  That is, Marxism.  Were some of these people duped for a time into being "Fellow Travelers" of the Soviet experiment?  Absolutely.  Did having shown an interest in Marxist ideology somehow render such Americans unpatriotic?  It did not.  But Senator Joseph McCarthy thought so, and he would make life hell for thousands of Americans who had done nothing wrong.

Theories are neither good nor bad.  Any theory, no matter how outlandish, can generate fruitful hypothesis -- good questions -- that can then be checked against the facts.  Even a theory about UFOs could be the jolt that opens your eyes to the world, leading you to ask good questions, think critically.  Conversely, the most respectable of theories can prove disastrous when they turn people into a lazy "believers." For example, certain theories economists and financial managers have taken for granted.  Personally, when I read the petition that Van Jones signed, I was not the least bit interested in the group's pet theories, but curious as to whether any of their questions might have been worth asking.  Van Jones may well have signed the petition with a similar mindset. Of course, it's also possible that Jones saw the petition as a convenient way to thumb his nose at the Bush Adminiration -- a routine act of free speech in a free country.

If Obama meekly accepts the resignation of Van Jones, a new McCarthyism could be just around the corner.
__
Photo of Obama by Jotman.  FDL has posted a savvy political analysis of the whole affair.

Friday, September 4, 2009

Turkish ship spills oil off Madagascar, humpback whales dying

7 UPDATES

On August 26 a Turkish ship so poorly maintained that it had been banned from EU waters began to sink just off the southern tip of Madagascar, causing a large oil spill.  Humpback whales, their blowholes blocked by the oil, have begun washing up on beaches.

The humpback whale population of the Indian Ocean breeds this time of year off Reunion Island, about 800 kilometers northeast of where the 23 sailors abandoned ship.  According to Dispatch (S.Africa) the MS Gulser Ana, bound for India, was a few kilometres off Cape Sainte Marie.   The 189 meter-long ship was carrying 39,000 tons of phosphates when it caught on fire.  Dispatch quotes from L’Express de Madagascar:
. . . . vets were trying to save the beached whales, who were close to death after their blowholes had become blocked with diesel and oil.

The cause of the accident to the 189m-long, 30m-wide ship is still unclear. But a statement from Prime Minister’s Monja Roindefo’s office said the ship’s cargo comprised far great quantities of diesel and oil than initially thought.

The statement said the ship was carrying 500000 cubic metres of diesel and 700000 litres of motor oil, as well as an unspecified quantity of heavy fuel.

It was not clear how much fuel has already seeped into the water. The newspaper reported that around 400 cubic metres had leaked and that a stretch of the coastline had been blackened by the pollution.

This protected part of Madagascar’s coast is famous for its rich coral reefs, rare species of tortoise and the migrating humpback whales that pass by at this time of year en route to their breeding grounds off Reunion Island.

At Spotlight Madagascar, Sondra Fischer, a Peace Corps volunteer, and Sara LeHoullier, a grad student, blog about the oil spill, noting:
This is not the first time whales have had problems in Madagascar. In this photo, taken in June 2008, more than 100 whales are beached after getting caught in a bay near where Exxon Mobile was carrying out seismic surveys, but denies any  fault for the whale disaster.
On Aug. 4 2009 WWF reported that Exxon was also under fire for endangering Pacific grey whales in the vicinity of the Sakhalin I oil and gas project on northeast Sakhalin Island, in the Russian Far East.  The Madagascar catastrophe of June 2008 involved melon-headed whales which washed up on a beach in northwest Madagascar.  Blogger  Harinjaka and the NGO Fanamby were among the first to report (fr) and publish photos (mg) of this ecological disaster according to GV's Lova Rakotomolala who discussed these reports.

Patrick, a university student in Madagascar who works part time as a tour guide, blogged about finding a humpback whale washed-up on a beach on August 24, 2009.   On the same blog post, Patrick described what it is like to watch humpback whales playing: 
After Foulpointe, Ste Marie [Jotman: location of oil spill] also is a very nice island and has a very interesting thing to discover. For example at the end of this month, in there, there will be one festival called Tsola be. It’s a new cultural event to promote the tourism sector. It going to be one unforgettable moment for you because you’ll discover the real Ste Marians Midôla in that time and also you will see by your own eyes the whales playing along its very beautiful beach. What happened in Mananara-Nord [the discovery of the dead whale] proves that (there are lots of ) whales around there and they are ready to give you a very nice show. Your dream will become true. . . .This very special event serves to let this world know that Madagascar is getting back into the normal life after the recent political crisis.
The shipping disaster couldn't have happened at a worse time for the whales or the people of Madagascar  who are trying to preserve their spectacular coastline as an eco-reserve.

What is to be done?
Poorly maintained ships like the MS Gulser Ana must be kept off the high seas.  Some new regulations reflect an awareness of the risks ships pose to sea life.  By 2011, many ships traveling in Antarctic waters will be required to burn Light Marine Oil.  Regulating marine fuel not only protects fragile ecosystems, it is probably one of the most cost-effective measures we could take in the fight against climate change.   That's because emissions from low grade fuel are a primary source of black carbon (soot) which is the second major contributor to global warming after CO2. In fact, scientists believe that the fastest means of slowing climate change is to reduce soot emissions -- a lot of which comes from ships. 
____
Top photo: by Jotman, shows a wild humpback whale feeding on krill.  Map: via Voyage of the Odyssey website shows the migratory route -- major breeding and feeding grounds -- of the Humpback Whales in the Indian Ocean. "The dashed line shows the suspected spring and and fall migration routes. The solid lines show main routes."  

UPDATE 1 (correction): Whereas blogger Patrick refers to Sainte Marie Island (also known as Nosy Boraha), an island off the east coast of Madagascar’s Toamasina Province, the Turkish freighter MS Gulser Ana began to sink off Cape Sainte Marie which is the name for the southern most point of Madagascar, a desolate, windswept place with few human inhabitants.  According to Ecosnap, "Sainte Marie Island is 60 km long and less than 10 km wide. The channel between Sainte-Marie island and mainland Madagascar is a hot spot for whale watching. Substantial groups of humpback whales migrate from the Antarctic to this idyllic breeding place."     Both "Sainte Marie," though far apart, happen to be rich in wildlife and great places for whale watching.

UPDATE 2:  Besides the breeding humpbacks, another wild animal seriously threatened by the oil spill is the tortoise.  A parks website notes that "Cape Sainte Marie is a real heaven for the turtles: the reserve has one of the strongest densities of the world . . ."  An environmental summit early in 2008 warned that tortoise of Madagascar are at risk on account of poaching and the trade in endangered species.

UPDATE 3: M&C reports that "State television on Thursday evening showed the first images of the affected stretch of coast around Cap Sainte Marie, Madagascar's southernmost point. . . .  The television images showed blackened beaches, dead fish and the near-sunken ship." A scientist expressed concern that "The mammals could become disoriented by an oil slick and steer off course in which case the reproduction of the whales could be significantly disturbed.'

UPDATE 4:  Here is the registration information (2006) for the Turkish flag vessel MV Gulser Ana.  Here is a recent (Feb 2, 2009) photo of the vessel by traveling through the Panama Canal.  Another photo of the ship shown at right.

UPDATE 5: In 2001 the Gulser Ana was detained on account of safety violations observed during an inspection on a visit to Belfast harbor..   The inspectors wrote in their report (pdf): "Fuel oil emergency quick closing devices not operational" and  "Fire hoses not operationally ready."  Shortly after, four crewmen were injured in an accident involving the lifeboat.   At the time of the violation, the ship was apparently owned by T&R Shipping and Trading. Captain Bill Bennett who detained the vessel commented: "This is the third time that Gulser Ana has been detained in ten months. The deficiencies are serious and if this vessel had been allowed to sail there could have been serious implications for both the crew and the vessel." A photo published in the official UK report depicts the accident involving the lifeboat. 


UPDATE 6:  The Gulser Ana, a catamaran, and a whale:  In Nov. 2008 the Royal Gazette reported that during stormy weather, the Gulser Ana rescued two crew members of a 42 foot catamaran near Bermuda.  "Their vessel was damaged after colliding with what they thought was a whale and started taking on water."   Here's a video of showing the rescue, some commentary here.  Most commentators thought the video depicted something fishy, perhaps because the website where the video had first been posted did not mention the prior collision with the whale.  Therefore, most viewers of the video assumed the Gulser Ana was deliberately trying to sink the catamaran!   S/V Maitreya (a blog) posted a video depicting the third rescue attempt. Maitreya observes "You don't really get the scale of the thing until you see the crew run down the deck."  True enough. 



UPDATE 7: "Clean-up operations ... have started and damage to the environment should be limited, the ship's operator said in a statement received by AFP Saturday" An AFP report continued:
"Sea currents are carrying any fuel oil to the east and away from the Cap Sainte Marie Marine Reserve and the coral reef, which should avoid any long or medium term environmental damage to the area," (the statement by the Mardeniz Denizcilik company) said.

"Over-flights of the area have not shown any evidence of whales or other sea mammals in the area having been in any way affected," it added. . . .

The island relies heavily on tourism and is home to two percent of the globe's total biodiversity. The majority of its animal and plant species are found nowhere else on Earth.

Marketing the Commander in Chief to a new generation

It's not part of any American tradition I have heard about.   Nevertheless, America's president is supposed to address school children on their first day of class (September 8).   Frankly, I'm surprised that only conservatives say they find this idea a bit creepy.  

Nevertheless, I have to admit that at practical level, an "address to the children" makes a certain amount of sense.  A new generation of Americans will be needed to fight Obama's war in Afghanistan over the next seven years.  An annual address is a chance for some kids to get to know their future Commander in Chief.     The dreams of today's twelve year old could make or break the Kandahar Offensive of 2015.  

If the United States is going to fight the long war in Afghanistan, its president needs to be proactive about recruitment.

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

Protecting free speech in an age of megaphones

In a previous post I quoted Mary, a Jotman reader, who expressed a desire to "stop" Fox News from spreading hatred of Obama in her community of rural Arkansas.  Some readers commented that everyone has the right to free speech, and that it is necessary to defend Fox, even if we strongly disagree with it.   

Mary's wish that Fox could be "stopped" did not strike me as an especially risky position, but a reasonable one under the circumstances.

The situation Mary described with respect to Fox News is analogous to a guy in the town square screaming into a megaphone. He won't shut up even for an hour. Nobody who is not his buddy gets a chance to be heard.

Although the guy with the megaphone has the right to speak, just because someone can afford to buy a megaphone does not mean he should be able to use it continuously, or keep it set at such a high volume that others cannot be heard. Free speech doesn't mean that the guy holding the biggest megaphone should be able to dictate who gets to speak and be heard and who doesn't.   It is right that the townsfolk should assemble and make rules governing the use of megaphones.   

Free speech is a means to an end, a way to ensure any ideas can be discussed, and so make for the betterment of yourself and your society. It's about having the best conversations possible.  It's about creating  opportunities to make informed decisions.

If all the megaphones are under the control of just a few companies with strong ties to the government, too many people do not get heard.  Then there is no conversation, no lively discussion of issues anymore. There may be "free speech" in a technical sense, but it cannot be very effective.

That's why I thought it was sensible for Mary to point a finger at the guy hogging the loudest megaphone and say: "Let's stop him" (from dominating the whole conversation).  

Too few megaphones in too few hands presents a serious problem. Regulating the use of megaphones should not be equated with taking away anyone's right to free speech.  Rather, it's a means of defending this right.
___
Photo by Jotman shows leaders of a May Day rally in Jakarta.