Showing posts with label Burma - relations with ASEAN. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Burma - relations with ASEAN. Show all posts

Monday, November 26, 2007

A more prominent logo will not rescue this brand.

I was amused to see this article on the front page of today's Bangkok Post:
Surin: Asean needs an identity

The Association of Southeast Asian Nations must get serious about creating its own brand and building a common identity to ensure a sound future for the grouping, says incoming Asean secretary-general Surin Pitsuwan. . .

"We have not seen much of the Asean fingerprint, the Asean logo. From now on we have to do a lot more," he said. . .

"People don't feel the concrete benefits from Asean . . . "
This report illustrates something that's very wrong with our world today; it points to a disease that infects so many organizations from Wall Street to Jakarta. Simply put, it's the widespread conviction that clever management can compensate for an absence of moral leadership.

Let there be no mistake: Asean's core values -- the basis for its identity and "brand" -- have already been determined. These were set forth by the heads of the organization's member countries when they met in Singapore. On the historic document which they signed in November, the stain of the Myanmar delegate's signature is indelible. With the stroke of a pen, the premier of Myanmar "branded" the organization.

A more prominent logo will not rescue this brand.

Photos:
Top photo from the
Myanmar Times. "A Vietnamese girl in traditional dress offers flowers to (Myanmar) Foreign Minister U Win Aung as he arrives at the annual retreat of ASEAN . . ." Bottom photo is from Al Jazeera. It depicts Singapore's PM Lee (right) with Myanmar premier Thein Sein. All other photos depicting Thein Sein at the recent Singapore meeting -- which I managed to locate by way of Google -- had been removed.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

ASEAN, Burma, and the great powers

In terms of the Burma crisis, have great powers influenced positions taken by individual Southeast Asian countries at the ASEAN summit in Singapore? Two of my favorite bloggers think so.

President Arroyo of the Philippines has warned that the Philippine Senate would have “extreme difficulty” ratifying new ASEAN charter unless Burma makes progress toward democracy and frees Aung San Suu Kyi. Greg of Ten Percent writes "This is mostly from US pressure and a mooted ‘free trade’ (shudder) deal. . ."

Meanwhile, Laos and Cambodia have condemned the Western economic sanctions and called on ASEAN member countries to stay out of each other's affairs. Blogger Fonzi at Thailand Jumped the Shark sees "China . . . exercising its power behind the scenes" here.

Friday, October 12, 2007

How Asean will defend it's "do nothing" approach to Burma

An informative piece in Singapore's Straights Times suggests how Asean leaders will try to talk themselves out of taking tough action against Burma:
It might come as cold comfort, but if it had not been for Burma's membership of Asean (Association of South- east Asian Nations) and five years of what the organisation calls "constructive engagement", the bloodshed in last month's monk-led protests could have been a lot worse.

Self-serving or not, Asean secretary-general Ong Keng Yong's assertion may hold some water. During the 1988 uprising in Burma, troops killed at least 3,000 protesters. This time the body count is anywhere between 13 and 130, with indications that, for all its brutality, Burma's military regime did hold back somewhat.

"We believe they did act with a certain restraint," Ong told The Straits Times. "They see a certain usefulness in Asean. They don't want to just walk away from the table. The situation could be a lot worse. They could be outside the membership and not give a damn about the rest of South-east Asia."

The real test, however, will come at the Nov 19-21 Asean summit in Singapore, when its leaders will have to deal with the perfect diplomatic storm - the crisis in Burma itself and a new charter giving the organisation the authority to expel a member for a breach of principles.

It's a highly informative article. Nevertheless, I think journalists have no business declaring the body count in Burma "is anywhere between 13 and 130" when the true figure could well be many times higher than 130.

I would refer journalists and Asean officials to this post. It summarizes -- and sources -- the big unknowns: reports of secret cremations, the massacre of monks, and the question as to whether Burma's hospitals had been ordered not to treat the wounded. Frankly, there are too many such reports from too many sources for anyone outside the Burmese junta to say they know how many died with such specificity. It's simply not possible to know the number of dead at this time. So let's stop pretending that any of the numbers we have are meaningful.

What we don't know about the extent of the crackdown in Burma far exceeds the extent of knowledge of the crackdown. There is still no working Internet in Burma! How many international news agencies even have correspondents in Rangoon?

The Asean leader's assertion of confidence in the regime and in the moderating impact of Burma's Asean membership is based on highly spurious figures that the world press has taken far too seriously. Journalists and politicians should not assume published figures of dead or missing Burmese present a valid reflection of the full scope of the terrible reality of what has happened and is presently occurring in Burma.

Because they do not.